The Value of the Humanities

Author:
  • HSHelen Small
    Helen Small

Abstract
This book is a critical study of the justifications for the humanities that have been most influential in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries and still exert persuasive power now. The main claims considered are: —that the humanities study the meaning-making practices of the culture, focusing on interpretation and evaluation, with an indispensable element of subjectivity; (relatedly) that there are grounds for discrimination here from the sciences and social sciences on the basis of the kind of work done, the culture of knowledge, and the character of the disciplines; —that the humanities are (laudably) at odds with, or at a remove from, instrumental use value; this has been a common line of resistance to political economists from Adam Smith onwards, and still tends to underwrite more recent descriptions of the humanities that demonstrate their contribution to the economy and to the social good; — that they contribute to the happiness of individuals and/or the general happiness of society; —that they are a force for democracy; —that they are good in themselves, or have value ‘for their own sake’. The Value of the Humanities has a dual purpose: it is a critical taxonomy, detailing the most commonly articulated arguments for the higher study of the humanities with the aim of clarifying their historical sources and lines of reasoning; it also seeks to test their validity for the present day, assessing their strengths and weaknesses and the part they can play in debate about the nature of public goods.