Abstract
Information Technology (IT), Information Systems (IS) and Computer Assisted Audit Techniques (CAAT) tools are common in auditing innovative environment. For instance, CAAT and associated auditing tools potentially enhance quality and enables auditors to achieve efficiency. However, audit firms still struggle to reduce resistance in the use of CAAT and other IT audit tools toward the plain compliance of the related standards. This study performs a comprehensive literature survey and analysis of frameworks of the main actors of the usage of IT audit tools. It toes the ISA 620 standard and the resistance theory. It further performs an in-dept analysis on the IT auditing tools in respect to application to auditing procedures. Findings show that the research concerning CAAT and IT auditing tools is increasing. So also, the networks of authors are going from the more traditional outlook spanning other frontiers. Findings also show that the application of IT tools generate more jobs and insights for the financial auditor while it spurs efficiency. We show that the adoption of the IT audit tools is strategically faced with conflicting priorities of the financial auditor inasmuch as the use of specialist is presently dominating the assurance services and it is hard to share from the acquired cake. The onus of application of innovative tools such as AI whose impact must be shared between the audit firm, and the client is yet under debate. We show that audit firms encourage compliance of ISA 620 where audit partners’ IT background strengthens the effective use of IT audit tools. We identified data from papers, frameworks and models that discusses the use of IT audit tools, in auditing. These constructed data were then categorised by technique, engagement phase, and attributes to enhance their effective usage. The analysis categorises into, IT auditing tools in lieu of dragged efficiency, ISA 620 adoption framework (620AF) resistance, overcoming regulatory and methodology hurdles, and identifying gaps for future research, and classifying topics mostly encountered in the literature. Overall, we contribute to the IT audit literature and practice by showing how engagement partners can be complaint with relevant standards and be less resistant and diffuse IT audit tools. The implications of this study to academia are apart from the traditional authors of IT/IS auditing and tools, other networks of authors need to be incentivised. Policy makers and assurance gatekeepers need to tighten their approaches to enhance compliance of ISA standards in the use of auditing tools in the auditing procedures.

This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit: