Beyond benefits and harms: Global patterns of conflicts, trade-offs and concurrencies in extensive livestock contributions to people and nature
Authors:
- Diego J. Soler-NavarroDSDiego J. Soler-Navarro
- Zebensui Morales-ReyesZMZebensui Morales-Reyes
- Alicia Tenza-PeralATAlicia Tenza-Peral
- Letícia Santos LimaLLLetícia Santos Lima
- Andrés GiménezAGAndrés Giménez
- Ismael Lare-DavidILIsmael Lare-David
- Francisco J. Lacosta-GarcíaFLFrancisco J. Lacosta-García
- Irene Pérez-IbarraIPIrene Pérez-Ibarra
Preprint
- 19 August 2026
- preprint
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract
Extensive livestock systems shape livelihoods, landscapes and ecological processes worldwide, yet their role in global environmental change remains contested. Research often documents isolated benefits or harms, but pays less attention to how multiple contributions to people and nature interact within the same social-ecological systems. We address this gap through a systematic global review of 908 peer-reviewed articles, covering 1393 case studies from 93 countries. Using an adapted Nature’s Contributions to People framework, we classified reported livestock-related contributions as material, non-material or regulating, and coded their effects as beneficial, detrimental or undetermined. We then analysed how explicitly reported beneficial and detrimental effects interacted through concurrencies, trade-offs and conflicts. Regulating contributions dominated the evidence base across all effect types, while material and especially non-material contributions were far less represented. Detrimental effects were more frequently reported than beneficial effects, although many studies described effects without assigning a clear direction. Interactions among contribution categories were reported in less than half of case studies and were dominated by concurrencies, particularly detrimental relationships among organisms, soils and habitats. Their variation across regions and livestock-system types indicates that the effects of extensive livestock are strongly context dependent rather than inherently beneficial or detrimental. The predominance of regulating contributions also reveals an ecological bias in the evidence base and highlights the limited consideration of material and non-material dimensions. These findings show that sustainable policy and valuation frameworks should move beyond single-effect assessments and explicitly address bundles of benefits, harms and trade-offs.Keywords
This publication has 58 references indexed in Scilit:
- Nature’s contribution to people provided by pastoral systems across European, African, and Middle East Mediterranean countries: trends, approaches and gapsRegional Environmental Change, 2024
- Intensification differentially affects the delivery of multiple ecosystem services in subtropical and temperate grasslandsAgriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 2023
- Culling recolonizing mesopredators increases livestock losses: Evidence from the South African KarooAMBIO, 2019
- Variability and Change in Maasai Views of Wildlife and the Implications for ConservationHuman Ecology, 2019
- Ecosystem functions in mixed cropland–grassland systems influenced by soil legacies of past crop cultivation decisionsEcosphere, 2018
- Mediterranean cork oak wooded grasslands: synergies and trade-offs between plant diversity, pasture production and soil carbonAgroforestry Systems, 2018
- Impacts of Intensive Livestock Production on Human Health in Densely Populated RegionsGeoHealth, 2017
- Aridity and Overgrazing Have Convergent Effects on Ecosystem Structure and Functioning in Patagonian RangelandsLand Degradation & Development, 2017
- The Challenges of Incorporating Cultural Ecosystem Services into Environmental AssessmentAMBIO, 2013
- Appreciation, Use, and Management of Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services in California’s Working LandscapesEnvironmental Management, 2012