Assessment of bias in morphological identification of carnivore scats confirmed with molecular scatology in north-eastern Himalayan region of Pakistan
Open Access
Abstract
Scats are often used to study ecological parameters of carnivore species. However, field identification of carnivore scats, based on their morphological characteristics, becomes difficult if many carnivore species are distributed in the same area. We assessed error rates in morphological identification of five sympatric carnivores’ scats in north-eastern Himalayan region of Pakistan during 2013–2017. A sample of 149 scats were subjected to molecular identification using fecal DNA. We used a confusion matrix to assess different types of errors associated with carnivore scat identification. We were able to amplify DNA from 96.6% (n = 144) of scats. Based on field identification of carnivore scats, we had predicted that out of 144 scats: 11 (7.6%) scats were from common leopard, 38 (26.4%) from red fox, 29 (20.1%) from Asiatic jackal, 37 (25.7%) from yellow throated martin, 14 (9.7%) from Asian palm civet and 15 (10.4%) from small Indian civet. However, molecular identification revealed and confirmed nine were scats (6.24%) from common leopard, 40 (27.8 %) from red fox, 21 (14.6%) from Asiatic jackal, 45 (31.25%) from Asian palm civet, 12 (8.3%) scats from small Indian civet, while 11 scats (7.6%) were found from Canis lupus Spp., three (2%) from dog, one (0.7 %) scat sample from porcupine, and two (1.4%) from rhesus monkey. Misidentification rate was highest for Asian palm civet (25.7%), followed by red fox (11.1%) and Asiatic jackal (9.7%) but least for common leopard scats (4.2%). The results specific to our study area concur with previous studies that have recommended that carnivore monitoring programs utilize molecular identification of predator scats. Using only morphological identification of scats can be misleading and may result in wrong management decisions.Keywords
Funding Information
- Higher Education Commission Pakistan
This publication has 47 references indexed in Scilit:
- Non-invasive genetic identification of two sympatric sister-species: ocelot (Leopardus pardalis) and margay (L. wiedii) in different biomesConservation Genetics Resources, 2018
- Distribution pattern, population estimation and threats to the Indian Pangolin Manis crassicaudata (Mammalia: Pholidota: Manidae) in and around Pir Lasura National Park, Azad Jammu & Kashmir, PakistanJournal of Threatened Taxa, 2017
- Food habits of the snow leopard Panthera uncia (Schreber, 1775) in Baltistan, Northern PakistanEuropean Journal of Wildlife Research, 2011
- Advancing ecological understandings through technological transformations in noninvasive geneticsMolecular Ecology Resources, 2009
- Perspectives on over-marking: is it good to be on top?Journal of Ethology, 2006
- Identifying species from pieces of faecesConservation Genetics, 2004
- On the origin of faeces: morphological versus molecular methods for surveying rare carnivores from their scatsJournal of Zoology, 2002
- Diet of the maned wolf, Chrysocyon brachyurus (Mammalia: Canidae), during wet and dry seasons at Ibitipoca State Park, BrazilJournal of Zoology, 2001
- Dietary separation of sympatric carnivores identified by molecular analysis of scatsMolecular Ecology, 2000
- Observer error in counts of macropod scatsWildlife Research, 2000