‘The wisdom of crowds’: a survey on the rating of nutritional values of meals in digital pictures
Open Access
- 20 June 2025
- journal article
- Published by BMJ in BMJ Nutrition, Prevention & Health
- Vol. 8 (1) , 184-191
Abstract
Background: Photo-based nutrition diaries might be useful to assess dietary intake without much effort and maybe even without nutrition expertise. This proof-of-concept study aimed to investigate the principle of ‘the wisdom of crowds’ by examining how accurately both nutrition experts and non-experts can rate nutritional values of meals presented in digital pictures. Methods: An online survey was conducted among adults in Germany from 2016 to 2017. Participants rated a random selection of six meal pictures according to their nutritional values (energy, carbohydrates, sugar and fat content) and their healthiness. Rating results were compared with the nutritional value calculated by the German Nutrient Database or according to the manufacturer’s information (‘truth’). Descriptive statistical analysis, Mann-Whitney-U test and multiple linear regression analysis were performed using RStudio. Results: In total, 110 (92.7 % women, mean age: 38.7±14.0 years) nutrition experts and 233 (31.3 % women, mean age: 21.2±2.6 years) non-experts participated. Overall meal pictures, experts overestimated the average content of all nutritional values (sugar: 3.8 %, energy: 4.9 %, carbohydrates: 4.9 % and fat: 10.4 %). Non-experts overestimated the average energy content by 10.4 %, fat content by 17.1 % and sugar content by 27.5%. The average carbohydrate content was underestimated by 9.0%. A statistically significant difference between the two crowds’ ratings was found for energy (p=0.03), carbohydrates (p<0.001) and sugar (p<0.001), but not for fat (p=0.44). An increasing deviation of nutritional value ratings from the truth towards overrating was associated with decreasing rating of healthiness (all p<0.001). Conclusion: This study suggests that both experts and non-experts rate nutritional values of meals in digital pictures in an appropriate manner, although both crowds occasionally deviated significantly from the truth, especially over-rating occurred with decreasing rating of healthiness. Due to the proof-of-concept approach and the limited generalisability of the results, the principle of ‘the wisdom of crowds’ is not fully supported. Studies with a large representative population are necessary. However, findings suggest that crowd-based meal picture ratings could be a method of digital dietary self-monitoring in combination with gamification elements.Keywords
Funding Information
- Bundesministerium für Forschung, Technologie und Raumfahrt (01EA1409H)
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- A matter of the metric? Sugar content overestimation is less pronounced in sugar cubes versus gramsNutrition Research, 2024
- AI-based digital image dietary assessment methods compared to humans and ground truth: a systematic reviewAnnals of Medicine, 2023
- A systematic review of the use of dietary self-monitoring in behavioural weight loss interventions: delivery, intensity and effectivenessPublic Health Nutrition, 2021
- Self‐Monitoring via Digital Health in Weight Loss Interventions: A Systematic Review Among Adults with Overweight or ObesityObesity, 2021
- The effectiveness of app‐based mobile interventions on nutrition behaviours and nutrition‐related health outcomes: A systematic review and meta‐analysisObesity Reviews, 2019
- Measuring diet in the 21st century: use of new technologiesProceedings of the Nutrition Society, 2016
- Detecting and tagging users’ social circles in social mediaMultimedia Systems, 2014
- The Behavior Change Technique Taxonomy (v1) of 93 Hierarchically Clustered Techniques: Building an International Consensus for the Reporting of Behavior Change InterventionsAnnals of Behavioral Medicine, 2013
- Think before you eat: photographic food diaries as intervention tools to change dietary decision making and attitudesInternational Journal of Consumer Studies, 2008
- Individual differences in food perceptions and calorie estimation: An examination of dieting status, weight, and genderAppetite, 2007