The Enlightenment rejection of the Cartesian mechanistic understanding of animals was accompanied by a (re)new(ed) anticruelty sentiment. Compassion, however, fell victim to the triumph of reason leading Western culture toward an era of cruelty to animals on an unprecedented scale. What was absent in Enlightenment thought, even among proponents of humane treatment of animals, was a fundamental change in understanding of the relationship between human and other-than-human creatures. A new understanding of animals, as exemplified in Andrew Linzey s animal theology has the potential not only to liberate animals from cruel oppression, but to emancipate Western thought from the idols of modernity.