Attractor-like Dynamics in Belief Updating in Schizophrenia
Open Access
- 5 September 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Society for Neuroscience in The Journal of Neuroscience
- Vol. 38 (44) , 9471-9485
Abstract
Subjects with a diagnosis of schizophrenia (Scz) overweight unexpected evidence in probabilistic inference: such evidence becomes “aberrantly salient.” A neurobiological explanation for this effect is that diminished synaptic gain (e.g., hypofunction of cortical NMDARs) in Scz destabilizes quasi-stable neuronal network states (or “attractors”). This attractor instability account predicts that (1) Scz would overweight unexpected evidence but underweight consistent evidence, (2) belief updating would be more vulnerable to stochastic fluctuations in neural activity, and (3) these effects would correlate. Hierarchical Bayesian belief updating models were tested in two independent datasets (n= 80 male andn= 167 female) comprising human subjects with Scz, and both clinical and nonclinical controls (some tested when unwell and on recovery) performing the “probability estimates” version of the beads task (a probabilistic inference task). Models with a standard learning rate, or including a parameter increasing updating to “disconfirmatory evidence,” or a parameter encoding belief instability were formally compared. The “belief instability” model (based on the principles of attractor dynamics) had most evidence in all groups in both datasets. Two of four parameters differed between Scz and nonclinical controls in each dataset: belief instability and response stochasticity. These parameters correlated in both datasets. Furthermore, the clinical controls showed similar parameter distributions to Scz when unwell, but were no different from controls once recovered. These findings are consistent with the hypothesis that attractor network instability contributes to belief updating abnormalities in Scz, and suggest that similar changes may exist during acute illness in other psychiatric conditions.SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENTSubjects with a diagnosis of schizophrenia (Scz) make large adjustments to their beliefs following unexpected evidence, but also smaller adjustments than controls following consistent evidence. This has previously been construed as a bias toward “disconfirmatory” information, but a more mechanistic explanation may be that in Scz, neural firing patterns (“attractor states”) are less stable and hence easily altered in response to both new evidence and stochastic neural firing. We model belief updating in Scz and controls in two independent datasets using a hierarchical Bayesian model, and show that all subjects are best fit by a model containing a belief instability parameter. Both this and a response stochasticity parameter are consistently altered in Scz, as the unstable attractor hypothesis predicts.Keywords
This publication has 57 references indexed in Scilit:
- Trading Speed and Accuracy by Coding Time: A Coupled-circuit Cortical ModelPLOS Computational Biology, 2013
- Punishment-Induced Behavioral and Neurophysiological Variability Reveals Dopamine-Dependent Selection of Kinematic Movement ParametersJournal of Neuroscience, 2013
- The Roles of Reward, Default, and Executive Control Networks in Set-Shifting Impairments in SchizophreniaPLOS ONE, 2013
- Linking Microcircuit Dysfunction to Cognitive Impairment: Effects of Disinhibition Associated with Schizophrenia in a Cortical Working Memory ModelCerebral Cortex, 2012
- Has an Angel Shown the Way? Etiological and Therapeutic Implications of the PCP/NMDA Model of SchizophreniaSchizophrenia Bulletin, 2012
- Bayesian modelling of Jumping-to-Conclusions bias in delusional patientsCognitive Neuropsychiatry, 2011
- Probabilistic learning and inference in schizophreniaSchizophrenia Research, 2011
- A Bayesian foundation for individual learning under uncertaintyFrontiers in Human Neuroscience, 2011
- Bayesian model selection for group studiesNeuroImage, 2009
- Reasoning Anomalies Associated With Delusions in SchizophreniaSchizophrenia Bulletin, 2008