Photogrammetry Versus Intraoral Scanning in Complete‐Arch Digital Implant Impression: A Systematic Review and Meta‐Analysis
Top Cited Papers
Open Access
- 7 June 2025
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Wiley in Clinical Implant Dentistry and Related Research
- Vol. 27 (3) , e70059
Abstract
Statement of the Problem: The application of digital impressions for complete‐arch implant supported fixed dental prostheses (FDP) remains controversial, and data from a systematic review with meta‐analysis comparing intraoral scanning (IOS) and stereophotogrammetry (SPG) remain limited.Purpose: To evaluate and compare the accuracy of currently available digital technologies, specifically IOS and SPG, in capturing complete‐arch implant impressions.Materials and Methods: An electronic and manual search was conducted on May 4, 2024, across PubMed, Embase, and Cochrane CENTRAL databases following PRISMA guidelines. The search targeted studies (excluding case reports) that assessed the in vivo, in vitro, or ex vivo accuracy of IOS and SPG for complete‐arch implant impressions. Two investigators screened eligible studies using the QUADAS‐2 tool. Accuracy was the primary outcome, including linear, angular, surface deviations, and inter‐implant distance. Three meta‐analyses were performed on angular deviations, trueness, and surface deviations, trueness, and precision using a random‐effect model.Results: Thirteen studies (3 in vivo and 10 in vitro) met inclusion criteria, displaying methodological heterogeneity (8 analyzing surface, 3 linear, 8 angular, and 3 interimplant distance deviations). The studies evaluated seven IOS (Aoralscan 3, Carestream 3600, iTero Element 2, iTero Element 5D, Primescan, Trios 3, and Trios 4) and two SPG devices (PIC and ICam4D). The number of implants ranged from 4 to 8. SPG reported higher accuracy than IOS in 10 of 13 studies. One in vitro study found IOS to have higher trueness but lower precision, another in vitro study found higher accuracy with IOS, and one in vivo study showed comparable trueness. Meta‐analyses of in vitro studies revealed significant differences favoring SPG in surface deviation trueness and precision, and angular deviation trueness (p < 0.05), with reported effects of 3.426, 4.893, and 1.199. SPG showed surface trueness and precision, and angular trueness mean ranges 5.18–48.74 and 0.10–5.46 μm, and 0.24°–0.80°, while IOS ranges 14.8–67.72 and 3.90–37.07 μm, and 0.28°–1.74°.Conclusions: Within study limitations, SPG showed to be a more reliable technology than IOS for complete‐arch digital implant impression, exhibiting significantly greater trueness and precision. IOS reported an angular deviation exceeding the 1° threshold required for a passive fit. Further clinical trials are required for conclusive evidence. Until then, a rigid prototype try‐in is still recommended.Trial Registration: CRD42024490844Keywords
This publication has 46 references indexed in Scilit:
- Fit of CAD/CAM Implant Frameworks: A Comprehensive ReviewJournal of Oral Implantology, 2014
- Using stereophotogrammetric technology for obtaining intraoral digital impressions of implantsThe Journal of the American Dental Association, 2014
- Clinical and Radiologic Experience with Moderately Rough Oxidized Titanium Implants: Up to 10 Years of Retrospective Follow-upThe International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Implants, 2014
- Optimal number of oral implants for fixed reconstructions: a review of the literature.2014
- Different implant impression techniques for edentulous patients treated with CAD/CAM complete-arch prostheses: a randomised controlled trial reporting data at 3 years post-loading2013
- QUADAS-2: A Revised Tool for the Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy StudiesAnnals of Internal Medicine, 2011
- Comparisons of precision of fit between cast and CNC-milled titanium implant frameworks for the edentulous mandible.2003
- Mechanical complications of dental implantsClinical Oral Implants Research, 2000
- Photogrammetry--an alternative to conventional impressions in implant dentistry? A clinical pilot study.2000
- Accuracy of implant‐supported prostheses in the edentulous jaw. Analysis of precision of fit between cast gold‐alloy frameworks and master casts by means of a three‐dimensional photogrammetric technique.Clinical Oral Implants Research, 1995