The Regulatory Welfare State in Pension Markets: Mitigating High Charges for Low-Income Savers in the United Kingdom and Israel
- 10 August 2016
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Social Policy
- Vol. 46 (2) , 313-330
Abstract
How does the rising ‘regulatory welfare state’ address social policy concerns in pension markets? This study examines this question by comparing the regulatory responses to high charges paid by low-income workers in pension markets in the UK and Israel. In the UK, with the recognition that the market would not cater to low-income workers, the regulatory response was the creation of a publicly operated low-cost pension fund (NEST), a ‘public option’ within the market. This allowed low-income workers access to a low level of charges, previously reserved for high-income and organised workers. In Israel, regulation sought to empower consumers, while providing minimal social protection by capping pension charges at a relatively high level, thereby leaving most of the responsibility for reducing the charges with the individual saver. By comparing these two cases, the article develops an analytical framework for the study of the regulatory welfare state, making two contributions. First, it highlights different types of regulatory citizenship: minimal regulatory social protection as opposed to a more egalitarian approach. Second, it identifies an overlooked regulatory welfare state strategy: creating ‘public option’ arrangements, whereby a state-run (but not funded) service operates within the market.Keywords
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- Strengthening Market Principles in Welfare Institutions: How Hybrid Pension Systems Impact on Social-risk SpreadingJournal of Social Policy, 2013
- NEW FORMS OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW IN THE AGE OF THIRD‐PARTY GOVERNMENTPublic Administration, 2012
- The historical roots of a diffusion process: The three-pillar doctrine and European pension debates (1972–1994)Global Social Policy, 2012
- Pension privatization in a welfare state environment: socializing private pensions in Germany and the United KingdomJournal of Comparative Social Welfare, 2012
- Is there an extended family of Mediterranean welfare states?Journal of European Social Policy, 2010
- Regulating-for-Welfare: A Comparative Study of “Regulatory Welfare Regimes” in the Israeli, British, and Swedish Electricity SectorsLaw & Policy, 2010
- Re‐Bureaucratizing Welfare AdministrationSocial Service Review, 2010
- Three Steps to Heaven? Tensions in the Management of Welfare: Retirement Pensions and Active ConsumersJournal of Social Policy, 2005
- How well does a partnership in pensions really work? The Israeli public/private pension mixAgeing and Society, 2002
- Quasi-Markets and Social PolicyThe Economic Journal, 1991