Practical and Procedural Obstacles to a Functional Investor-State Dispute Settlement Mechanism in the Andean Community: Why Secondary Legislation Is not Enough?
Open Access
- 22 July 2026
- journal article
- Published by Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico in Mexican Law Review
- p. e21204
Abstract
This article analyzes the legal and institutional barriers to establishing a functional Investor-State Dispute Settlement mechanism within the Court of Justice of the Andean Community. Using a comparative regional integration law methodology—with reference to the European Union, EFTA, and Mercosur—the article evaluates the structural requirements for this institutional reform. We found that successful operationalization is hindered by a “treaty tarrier” that requires a formal amendment to the constituent treaty, as secondary legislation is insufficient to expand jurisdiction. Furthermore, the analysis identifies critical needs for a specialized roster of independent arbitrators, robust transparency standards, and a standing appellate mechanism. It also highlights severe budgetary deficits and proposes judicial fees and trust funds to ensure financial sustainability. Finally, the article underscores the urgency of modernizing outdated substantive investment standards to align them with contemporary international law. It is concluded that a legitimate Andean arbitral forum requires a comprehensive, rather than superficial, normative and institutional overhaul to resolve contemporary disputes effectively.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- La autonomía del derecho comunitario andino y su relación con el derecho internacionalRevista de La Secretaría Del Tribunal Permanente de Revisión, 2016
- La Comunidad Andina de Naciones y la evolución del proceso de integracion socioeconómico en latinoaméricaEstudios de Deusto, 2016
- Collective identity in the andean community: An institutional accountPapel Político, 2016
- The EFTA Court: Structure and Tasks2015
- The Andean Community of Nations2015
- Enforcement and Escape in theAndean Community: Why theAndean Community of Nations is Not a Replica of theEuropean UnionJCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies, 2014
- El No Positivismo IncluyenteDoxa. Cuadernos de Filosofía del Derecho, 2013
- Legal Integration in the Andes: Law‐Making by the Andean Tribunal of JusticeEuropean Law Journal, 2011
- Nature or Nurture? Judicial Lawmaking in the European Court of Justice and the Andean Tribunal of JusticeInternational Organization, 2010
- The Advocate General and EC Law2007