Uncertainty, identifiability and the propagation of prediction errors: A case study of lake ontario
Authors:
- 1 January 1991
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Forecasting
- Vol. 10 (1-2) , 135-161
Abstract
Most models of environmental systems can be expected to suffer, to a varying extent, from a lack of identifiability. Overparameterization seems both intrinsic and an intractable problem. As a result, interpretation of past observed behaviour through a model is ambiguous, and this will have obvious implications for any predictions of future behaviour. There has been much study of this issue of uncertainty in environmental modelling, yet very limited investigation of its consequences in the use of larger‐scale models. The paper examines some of these consequences for a model of the carbon and phosphorus cycles in Lake Ontario having 24 state variables and thirteen parameters. Filtering theory is used to provide both the conceptual framework for the analysis and a specific, recursive algorithm for the propagation of a variance‐covariance matrix of state prediction errors. Special attention is given to examining the ambiguities that may arise in the making of predictions, and the possibility of generating contradictory statements about future behaviour is introduced. It is found that with this relatively large model the propagation of prediction error variances is insensitive to the degree of correlation among the parameter‐estimation errors and to changes of the nominal estimated values of small subsets of parameters.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Identifying flow paths in models of surface water acidificationReviews of Geophysics, 1990
- Lake Erie Research: Recent Results, Remaining GapsJournal of Great Lakes Research, 1987
- Oxygen Depletion in Lake Erie: Modeling the Physical, Chemical, and Biological Interactions, 1972 and 1979Journal of Great Lakes Research, 1987
- Lake Erie Thermocline Model Results: Comparison with 1967–1982 Data and Relation to Anoxic OccurrencesJournal of Great Lakes Research, 1987
- Maximum Likelihood Estimation of Parameters and Uncertainty in Phytoplankton Models1983
- Uncertainty, System Identification, and the Prediction of Water Quality1983
- Variance estimates for a dynamic eutrophication model of Saginaw Bay, Lake HuronWater Resources Research, 1981
- Comparison of first‐order error analysis and Monte Carlo Simulation in time‐dependent lake eutrophication modelsWater Resources Research, 1981
- Asymptotic behavior of the extended Kalman filter as a parameter estimator for linear systemsIEEE Transactions on Automatic Control, 1979
- Numerical comparison of kalman filter algorithms: Orbit determination case studyAutomatica, 1977