Abstract
Supercritical CO2 is a promising cushion gas for underground natural gas storage (UGS), but long-term CO2-CH4 mixing may compromise working-gas recovery and produced-gas quality under cyclic operation. This study develops a field-scale multiphase, multicomponent model within the PFLOTRAN-OGS framework to simulate cyclic two-phase flow, CO2 dissolution/exsolution in formation water, and compositional dispersion during cushion-gas replacement and subsequent storage operation. The model is applied to a depleted anticlinal reservoir and couples an initial CO2 replacement stage with 19 annual injection-withdrawal cycles over 20 years. Results show that the CO2-CH4 mixing zone thickens progressively at an average rate of about 1 m/yr, accompanied by cycle-induced sawtooth fluctuations of 5-8 m. Increasing the CO2 cutoff pressure from 16 to 24 MPa improves CH4 displacement, but the working-gas volume reaches a maximum at 20 MPa, yielding a 6.0% increase over the baseline case, and then declines as excess CO2 occupies pore space. At this condition, the produced-gas purity remains above 98% throughout the 20-year operation period. Multi-objective analysis further reveals a clear trade-off among storage capacity, gas purity, and operational conditions, indicating that lower temperature, lower porosity, weaker permeability anisotropy, and a production interval placed farther from the basal CO2-rich zone are favorable for mitigating CO2 breakthrough. These results provide quantitative guidance for the design and operation of CO2-cushioned UGS systems.

This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit: