Advancing AI Negotiations: New Theory and Evidence from a Large-Scale Autonomous Negotiations Competition
Authors:
- Michelle VaccaroMVMichelle Vaccaro
- Michael CaosonMCMichael Caoson
- Harang JuHJHarang Ju
- Sinan AralSASinan Aral
- Jared R. CurhanJCJared R. Curhan
Preprint
Abstract
Despite the rapid proliferation of artificial intelligence (AI) negotiation agents, there has been limited integration of computer science research and established negotiation theory to develop new theories of AI negotiation. To bridge this gap, we conducted an International AI Negotiations Competition in which participants iteratively designed and refined prompts for large language model (LLM) negotiation agents. We then facilitated over 120,000 negotiations between these agents across multiple scenarios with diverse characteristics and objectives. Our findings revealed that fundamental principles from established human-human negotiation theory remain crucial in AI-AI negotiations. Specifically, agents exhibiting high warmth fostered higher counterpart subjective value and reached deals more frequently, which enabled them to create and claim more value in integrative settings. However, conditional on reaching a deal, warm agents claimed less value while dominant agents claimed more value. These results align with classic negotiation theory emphasizing relationship-building, assertiveness, and preparation. Our analysis also revealed unique dynamics in AI-AI negotiations not fully explained by negotiation theory, particularly regarding the effectiveness of AI-specific strategies like chain-of-thought reasoning and prompt injection. The agent that won our competition implemented an approach that blended traditional negotiation preparation frameworks with AI-specific methods. Together, these results suggest the importance of establishing a new theory of AI negotiations that integrates established negotiation theory with AI-specific strategies to optimize agent performance. Our research suggests this new theory must account for the unique characteristics of autonomous agents and establish the conditions under which traditional negotiation theory applies in automated settings.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- Negotiating with LLMs: Prompt Hacks, Skill Gaps, and Reasoning Deficits2025
- Short and extra-short forms of the Big Five Inventory–2: The BFI-2-S and BFI-2-XSJournal of Research in Personality, 2017
- Automated negotiation for e-commerce decision making: A goal deliberated agent architecture for multi-strategy selectionDecision Support Systems, 2015
- Estimating Standard Errors in Finance Panel Data Sets: Comparing ApproachesThe Review of Financial Studies, 2008
- Psychological Influence in Negotiation: An Introduction Long OverdueJournal of Management, 2008
- What do people value when they negotiate? Mapping the domain of subjective value in negotiation.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2006
- The Positive and Negative Affect Schedule (PANAS): Construct validity, measurement properties and normative data in a large non‐clinical sampleBritish Journal of Clinical Psychology, 2004
- Negotiator Relationships: Construct Measurement, and Demonstration of Their Impact on the Process and Outcomes of NegotiationGroup Decision and Negotiation, 1998
- Negotiator cognition and rationality: A behavioral decision theory perspectiveOrganizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 1992
- Psychometric and Geometric Characteristics of the Revised Interpersonal Adjective Scales (IAS-R)Multivariate Behavioral Research, 1988