The American Black Bear ( Ursus americanus ) as an Apex Predator: Investigating the Ecological Role of the World's Most Abundant Large Carnivore
Open Access
- 5 August 2025
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Mammal Review
- Vol. 56 (1)
Abstract
Introduction: American black bears ( Ursus americanus ) have been documented to have top‐down effects, both consumptive (through predation) and nonconsumptive (through fear effects). However, their behavioural and dietary adaptability has led to uncertainty about the conditions under which these may occur. Objectives: We aimed to (1) investigate when, where, and how often black bears influence lower trophic levels, and (2) critically assess the experimental design of such studies to determine trends and biases. Methods: We conducted a systematic literature search and used linear mixed‐effects models to assess the relationships among prey age class, the presence of other large carnivores, and the percentage of ungulate mortality due to black bears. We also summarised the measured effects of black bears on other carnivores and the results of any experimental studies. Results: We found a strong negative relationship between puma presence and the percentage of ungulate mortality due to black bears, but only in areas with at least one other large carnivore (e.g., wolves). Among 16 studies of black bears' impacts on other carnivores, most documented negative behavioural effects. While only 5% of studies had strong experimental design, bear removal consistently increased juvenile ungulate survival. Discussion and Synthesis: Our findings highlight black bears' strong top‐down effects, resembling or exceeding those of other large carnivores. These effects were greatest when no other large carnivores were present, but as highly effective kleptoparasites, black bears can alter the feeding habits of other large carnivores. Thus, we argue that ‘apex’ is a conditional state, not a species‐wide status.Keywords
This publication has 66 references indexed in Scilit:
- Survival, cause‐specific mortality, and population growth of white‐tailed deer in western VirginiaThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 2023
- No long‐term effect of black bear removal on elk calf recruitment in the southern AppalachiansThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 2023
- Of wolves and bears: Seasonal drivers of interference and exploitation competition between apex predatorsEcological Monographs, 2021
- White‐Tailed Deer Population Dynamics Following Louisiana Black Bear RecoveryThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 2020
- Predator densities and white‐tailed deer fawn survivalThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 2019
- Diel predator activity drives a dynamic landscape of fearEcological Monographs, 2018
- Manipulations of black bear and coyote affect caribou calf survivalThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 2016
- Dietary adjustability of grizzly bears and American black bears in Yellowstone National ParkThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 2012
- Effects of predator treatments, individual traits, and environment on moose survival in AlaskaThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 2011
- Effects of black bear relocation on elk calf recruitment at Great Smoky Mountains National ParkThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 2011