A Comparative Study on the Promoting Effects of Different Tourism Development Models on Rural Revitalization: Case Studies from Two Typical Villages in China
Open Access
- 17 January 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 17 (2) , 714
Abstract
This study aims to explore the pivotal role of rural tourism in addressing the “three rural issues” and promoting rural revitalization. This study selects two representative villages in China that adopt different models of tourism development: Shibadong Village in Huayuan County, Hunan Province, which adopts a government-led model, and Yuanjia Village in Lixian County, Shaanxi Province, which follows a community-led model. This study evaluates the impact of rural tourism on rural revitalization using the Entropy-TOPSIS method. Utilizing the IPA (Importance–Performance Analysis) method and an independent samples t-test, a comparative analysis of the two models was conducted to reveal the differences in the effects of rural tourism in promoting rural revitalization between the different models. This study reveals that rural tourism positively impacts the revitalization of rural industries, ecology, culture, talent, and organization. However, the effects of tourism in promoting rural revitalization vary across different tourism development models. This study further suggests that the “multiple interlocking model” may be the future trend of rural tourism development as it can better integrate the resources of the government, communities, and enterprises to achieve more effective rural revitalization. This study deepens the theoretical link between rural tourism and rural revitalization, providing concrete guidance for practice, especially in strategies that drive comprehensive rural revitalization through tourism. Future research should further explore the corporate-led model and the multiple interlocking model and track the evolution of tourism development models through longitudinal comparisons to adapt to the changing needs of rural development.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Social Science Foundation of China, Western China (16XGL008, 20XJY018, 42071186, 2017M623097, 2018KRM056, 2018Z076, 19DY14, 2021ND0237, 2020SZ01, 2023263)
- National Natural Science Foundation of China (16XGL008, 20XJY018, 42071186, 2017M623097, 2018KRM056, 2018Z076, 19DY14, 2021ND0237, 2020SZ01, 2023263)
- China Postdoctoral Science Foundation Project (16XGL008, 20XJY018, 42071186, 2017M623097, 2018KRM056, 2018Z076, 19DY14, 2021ND0237, 2020SZ01, 2023263)
- Soft Science Research Program Project of the Shaanxi Provincial Department of Science and Technology (16XGL008, 20XJY018, 42071186, 2017M623097, 2018KRM056, 2018Z076, 19DY14, 2021ND0237, 2020SZ01, 2023263)
- Research Project on Major Theoretical and Practical Issues in Social Sciences of Shaanxi Province (16XGL008, 20XJY018, 42071186, 2017M623097, 2018KRM056, 2018Z076, 19DY14, 2021ND0237, 2020SZ01, 2023263)
- Research Project on Culture, Art and Tourism of the Ministry of Culture and Tourism (16XGL008, 20XJY018, 42071186, 2017M623097, 2018KRM056, 2018Z076, 19DY14, 2021ND0237, 2020SZ01, 2023263)
- Research Project on Major Theoretical and Realistic Issues in Philosophy and Social Sciences of Shaanxi Province (16XGL008, 20XJY018, 42071186, 2017M623097, 2018KRM056, 2018Z076, 19DY14, 2021ND0237, 2020SZ01, 2023263)
- Project on the Prosperity of Philosophy and Social Sciences of Xi’an University of Science and Technology (16XGL008, 20XJY018, 42071186, 2017M623097, 2018KRM056, 2018Z076, 19DY14, 2021ND0237, 2020SZ01, 2023263)
- 2023 Shaanxi Provincial Sports Bureau Regular Project (16XGL008, 20XJY018, 42071186, 2017M623097, 2018KRM056, 2018Z076, 19DY14, 2021ND0237, 2020SZ01, 2023263)
This publication has 36 references indexed in Scilit:
- Assessing rural revitalization potential through rural transformation degree and sustainability: A quantitative study of 460 case villages in Lingbao, ChinaHabitat International, 2024
- Does rural tourism revitalize the countryside? An exploration of the spatial reconstruction through the lens of cultural connotations of ruralityJournal of Destination Marketing & Management, 2023
- How can tourism help to revitalize the countryside? Content analysis based on the case of tourism enabling rural revitalizationEnvironment, Development and Sustainability, 2023
- Tourist boom and rural revival — Case study of Klodzko Region (SW Poland)Journal of Mountain Science, 2022
- Rural smart tourism under the background of internet plusEcological Informatics, 2021
- Rural tourism: A systematic literature review on definitions and challengesJournal of Hospitality and Tourism Management, 2021
- China’s rural revitalization and development: Theory, technology and managementJournal of Geographical Sciences, 2020
- Coupling coordination analysis of rural production-living-ecological space in the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei regionEcological Indicators, 2020
- Tourism development and changing rural identity in ChinaAnnals of Tourism Research, 2017
- Rural tourism development in southeastern Europe: transition and the search for sustainabilityInternational Journal of Tourism Research, 2004