Epistemic authority in the digital public sphere. An integrative conceptual framework and research agenda
Top Cited Papers
Open Access
- 5 November 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Communication Theory
- Vol. 35 (1) , 37-50
Abstract
We develop an integrative conceptual framework and research agenda for studying epistemic authorities in the digital age. Consulting epistemic authorities (e.g., professional experts, well-informed laypeople, technologies) can be an efficient fast-track to knowledge. To fulfill this functional role, those who claim epistemic authority need to be both subjectively recognized (have a perceived advantage in knowledge) and objectively justified (have an actual advantage in knowledge). In a digital media context, new and unconventional knowledge sources have emerged that can fulfill the functional role of epistemic authorities. But false authorities that disseminate misinformation have emerged as well while other sources with important knowledge remain unrecognized. We further analyze the functional role of epistemic intermediaries that can mitigate such problematic developments by correcting false authorities and by providing endorsement for unrecognized authorities. We conclude with a research agenda to study functional forms of epistemic authorities and epistemic intermediaries in the digital public sphere.Keywords
This publication has 61 references indexed in Scilit:
- False AuthoritiesActa Analytica, 2024
- Conceptualizing and investigating post-truth politics: the geographic imagination and knowledge of the Flat Earth MovementGeoJournal, 2024
- Social Norms and Rules in Peer Production2020
- The social fabric of understanding: equilibrium, authority, and epistemic empathySynthese, 2020
- The epistemic division of labour in markets: knowledge, global trade and the preconditions of morally responsible agencyEconomics and Philosophy, 2019
- Beyond false balance: How interpretive journalism shapes media coverage of climate changeGlobal Environmental Change, 2017
- ExpertiseTopoi, 2016
- Says Who?: Epistemic Authority Effects in Social Judgment2005
- Bounded Rationality1990
- Lay Epistemics and Human Knowledge1989