In April 2025, President Trump announced US tariff increases. While the literature has been preoccupied with security of supply, the tariffs brought attention to export dependency. In the EU, one of the sectors with a high export dependency on the US is the wine sector. Leveraging high frequency export data on the universe of Italian wine exporters, this paper sheds new light on firm and product heterogeneity. Overall, we find that Italian wine exporters suffered both in export volume and prices, especially those who were dependent on the US market. At the product level, differentiated wines with Geographical Indications such as Chianti and Prosecco suffered less. In terms of the dynamics of the response, we find clear evidence of anticipatory stockpiling in the US, followed by a slump in imports. Overall, the data shows that export dependency is costly in times of rising protectionism, especially for less diversified commodities.