The discursive tactics of perpetuating white normativity in public education: A critical policy discourse analysis of anti-CRT policies across 18 states
Open Access
- 30 September 2025
- journal article
- Published by Mary Lou Fulton College for Teaching and Learning Innovation in Education Policy Analysis Archives
- Vol. 33
Abstract
In recent years, state policies banning “divisive concepts” have proliferated as part of a coordinated effort to undermine racial justice by framing critical discussions of race as “indoctrination” and imposing ideological restrictions on curriculum and pedagogy. Using critical policy discourse analysis informed by a critical study of whiteness, this paper examines how 22 policy documents from 18 states operate discursively to shape the parameters of race-related discourse in public education. Our findings suggest that these policies employ three primary discursive maneuvers: (1) constructing false equivalencies that equate white discomfort with racial oppression, (2) appealing to “universal” values to obscure systemic inequities, and (3) controlling definitional boundaries to determine what qualifies as racism and racial harm. These discursive maneuvers not only shape public perception and discourse but also work to preemptively silence conversations related to systemic racism in schools. This study underscores the importance of examining policy as discourse, revealing how language itself operates as a mechanism for maintaining racial hierarchies while presenting itself as neutral. These tactics extend beyond K–12 education, shaping rhetoric and policy in higher education and other public institutions.Keywords
This publication has 57 references indexed in Scilit:
- US teacher opposition to so-called critical race theory bansTeaching and Teacher Education, 2024
- What Do So‐Called Critical Race Theory Bans Mean for Elementary Literacy Instruction?Reading Research Quarterly, 2024
- The bans on teaching CRT and other ‘divisive concepts’ in America’s public schoolsJournal of Educational Administration and History, 2023
- Bans, sanctions, and dog-whistles: a review of anti-critical race theory initiatives adopted in the United States since 2020Policy Studies, 2023
- Critical race theory, books, and ChatGPT: Moving from a ban culture in education to a culture of restorationMiddle School Journal, 2023
- Resisting the Movement to Ban Critical Race Theory from SchoolsThe Clearing House: A Journal of Educational Strategies, Issues and Ideas, 2022
- But is it really about critical race theory?: The attack on teaching about systemic racism and why we must careMiddle School Journal, 2021
- “Racist-Blind, Not Color-Blind” by Design: Confronting Systemic Racism in Our Educational Past, Present, and FutureHistory of Education Quarterly, 2021
- Systemic racism and U.S. health careSocial Science & Medicine, 2014
- Applying Dialectical Models to the Trial2007