Is Human Handedness Universal? Ethological Analyses from Three Traditional Cultures
Authors:
Abstract
Right‐handedness inHomo sapiensis claimed to be qualitatively different from that of other primates, at species level, and to be universal across all cultures. Ethnographic indicators are sparse, however, being mostly indirect rather than direct observations of selected motor patterns. Ethological study of hand use, i.e. observation of a wide range of everyday behavioural patterns performed spontaneously, is missing. We coded such manual activity from cinematic archives of three traditional societies: G/wi San of Botswana, Himba of Namibia and Yanomamö of Venezuela. Results showed a consistent but weak right‐hand dominance across these three preliterate cultures. Most individuals showed mixed‐, rather than right‐handedness, irrespective of whether or not object manipulation was involved. The notable exception was tool use, which was markedly right‐handed, and only precision‐gripping tool use was normally performed exclusively with the right hand. Most questionnaires that measure handedness focus on precision tool use (and so are likely to be biased accordingly) rather than on more comprehensive ethological measures that include non‐object‐manipulatory, self‐directed and socially communicative patterns of behaviour.Keywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- Hand preferences for bimanual feeding in 140 captive chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes): Rearing and ontogenetic determinantsDevelopmental Psychobiology, 1994
- Laterality of function in apes: a meta-analysis of methodsJournal of Human Evolution, 1991
- Manual laterality in nonhuman primates: A distinction between handedness and manual specialization.Psychological Bulletin, 1991
- Multiple measures of motor lateralization in human primates (Homo sapiens).Journal of Comparative Psychology, 1990
- Laterality and human evolution.Psychological Review, 1989
- Different Dimensions of Hand Preference That Relate to Skilled and Unskilled ActivitiesCortex, 1989
- Impact of cultural pressures on self-reports of actual and approved hand useNeuropsychologia, 1987
- Concordance of handedness between teacher and student facilitates learning manual skillsJournal of Human Evolution, 1985
- The Pooling Fallacy: Problems Arising when Individuals Contribute More than One Observation to the Data SetZeitschrift Fur Tierpsychologie, 1985
- RETEST RELIABILITIES AND INTERRELATIONSHIP OF THE ANNETT HAND PREFERENCE QUESTIONNAIRE AND THE EDINBURGH HANDEDNESS INVENTORYBritish Journal of Psychology, 1975