When logical conclusions go against beliefs: an ERP study
- 13 November 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Language, Cognition and Neuroscience
- Vol. 33 (6) , 687-697
Abstract
Reasoning is a fundamental human ability, vulnerable to error. According to behavioural measures, we are biased to consider valid the conclusion of an argument based on the veracity of the conclusion itself rather than on the formal logic of the argument. Nowadays, brain imaging techniques can be used to explore peoplés responses as they reason with linguistic materials. Using the Event-Related Potential technique in a categorical syllogism reading task, an N400 enhancement was found for the processing of invalid conclusions preceded by true premises (e.g. All men are mortal). By contrast, when initial premises consisted of socially prejudiced statements previously rated as false (e.g. All blond girls are dumb), valid rather than invalid conclusions enhanced the N400 response. Considering what the modulation of N400 indexes (i.e. word anticipation processes), our data suggests that people cannot follow the logic of an argument to anticipate upcoming words if they clash with veracity.Keywords
Funding Information
- Ministerio de Economía y Competitividad
- MINECO (PSI2014-60682, PSI2015-68368-P-MINECO-FEDER)
- Comunidad Autonoma de Madrid (H2015/HUM-3327)
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- Uncertain deduction and conditional reasoningFrontiers in Psychology, 2015
- An ERP investigation of conditional reasoning with emotional and neutral contentsBrain and Cognition, 2014
- Disabling conditional inferences: An EEG studyNeuropsychologia, 2014
- Deduction electrified: ERPs elicited by the processing of words in conditional argumentsBrain and Language, 2013
- What's behind an inference? An EEG study with conditional argumentsNeuropsychologia, 2009
- Thinking ahead: The role and roots of prediction in language comprehensionPsychophysiology, 2007
- Probabilistic word pre-activation during language comprehension inferred from electrical brain activityNature Neuroscience, 2005
- On the conflict between logic and belief in syllogistic reasoningMemory & Cognition, 1983
- Atmosphere effect re-examined.Journal of Experimental Psychology, 1959
- On Methods in the Analysis of Profile DataPsychometrika, 1959