Exploring Cartographic Differences in Web Map Applications: Evaluating Design, Scale, and Usability
Preprint
- 12 November 2024
- preprint
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Abstract
Although there are many articles dealing with web map applications, they often focus on just one or a few applications. Several articles deal with the technical solution of the applications, but relatively few are focused on the cartographic aspects of these applications. This article evaluates eight web mapping applications based on six cartographic aspects: map key, map scale, map layout, navigation elements, labels, and analytical tools. The objective is to identify differences in the presentation of geographic information and propose improvements for cartographic quality and user-friendliness. The methodology involved visual analysis at two scales: large (1:100,000) and medium (1:500,000). The comparison included applications such as Mapy.cz, OpenStreetMap, Google Maps, Bing Maps, HERE Maps, MapQuest, ViaMichelin, and Locus Map. The results revealed significant differences among the applications that may impact user orientation and experience. For instance, Google Maps does not display forest symbols on its default map, which can reduce clarity, whereas Mapy.cz offers the most comprehensive range of analytical tools. Advertisements in applications like MapQuest and ViaMichelin disrupt the user experience, and some applications lack essential functions, such as distance measurement. The paper identifies strengths and weaknesses in the cartographic design of these applications. Findings reveal that while each application possesses unique characteristics, they share common features. An interesting feature is the absence of cartographic symbols and labels of some elements in some applications. The study recommends the unification of cartographic standards and further user testing to optimize the layout and functionality of web mapping applications.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Missing the city for buildings? A critical review of pan-scalar map generalization and design in contemporary zoomable mapsInternational Journal of Cartography, 2023
- Swipe versus multiple view: a comprehensive analysis using eye-tracking to evaluate user interaction with web mapsCartography and Geographic Information Science, 2022
- Web Map Effectiveness in the Responsive Context of the Graphical User InterfaceISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information, 2021
- Progressive Evolution of Designing Internet Maps on the example of Google MapsGeodesy and Cartography, 2019
- Online Map Services: Contemporary Cartography or a New Cartographic Culture?ISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information, 2019
- Review of Web Mapping: Eras, Trends and DirectionsISPRS International Journal of Geo-Information, 2017
- Cognitive Aspects of Map Symbology in the World School AtlasesProcedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 2014
- Addressing Map Interface Usability: Learning from the Lakeshore Nature Preserve Interactive MapCartographic Perspectives, 2008
- Usability Evaluation of Web Mapping SitesThe Cartographic Journal, 2008
- Exploratory cartographic visualization: Advancing the agendaComputers & Geosciences, 1997