Nasopharyngeal Swabs vs. Nasal Aspirates for Respiratory Virus Detection: A Systematic Review
Open Access
Abstract
Nasal pathogen detection sensitivities can be as low as 70% despite advances in molecular diagnostics. This may be linked to the choice of sampling method. A diagnostic test accuracy review for sensitivity was undertaken to compare sensitivity of swabbing to the nasopharynx and extracting nasal aspirates, using the PRISMA protocol, Cochrane rapid review methodology, and QUADAS-2 risk of bias tools, with meta-analysis of included studies. Sensitivities were calculated by a consensus standard of positivity by either method as the ‘gold standard.’ Insufficient sampling methodology, cross sectional study designs, and studies pooling samples across anatomical sites were excluded. Of 13 subsequently eligible studies, 8 had ‘high’ risk of bias, and 5 had ‘high’ applicability concerns. There were no statistical differences in overall sensitivities between collection methods for eight different viruses, and this did not differ with use of PCR, immunofluorescence, or culture. In one study alone, Influenza H1N1(2009) favored nasopharyngeal swabs, with aspirates having 93.3% of the sensitivity of swabs (p > 0.001). Similarly equivocal sensitivities were noted in reports detecting bacteria. The chain of sampling, from anatomical site to laboratory results, features different potential foci along which sensitivity may be lost. A fair body of evidence exists that use of a different sampling method will not yield more respiratory pathogens.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 52 references indexed in Scilit:
- Comparison among nasopharyngeal swab, nasal wash, and oropharyngeal swab for respiratory virus detection in adults with acute pharyngitisBMC Infectious Diseases, 2013
- Evaluation of a new immunochromatographic assay for rapid identification of influenza A, B, and A(H1N1)2009 virusesJournal of Infection and Chemotherapy, 2013
- Alternative Sampling Methods for Detecting Bacterial Pathogens in Children with Upper Respiratory Tract InfectionsJournal of Clinical Microbiology, 2012
- Comparison of nasopharyngeal flocked swabs and nasopharyngeal wash collection methods for respiratory virus detection in hospitalized children using real-time polymerase chain reactionJournal of Virological Methods, 2012
- Viral Shedding and Clinical Illness in Naturally Acquired Influenza Virus InfectionsThe Journal of Infectious Diseases, 2010
- Dry cotton or flocked respiratory swabs as a simple collection technique for the molecular detection of respiratory viruses using real-time NASBAJournal of Virological Methods, 2008
- Comparison between Pernasal Flocked Swabs and Nasopharyngeal Aspirates for Detection of Common Respiratory Viruses in Samples from ChildrenJournal of Clinical Microbiology, 2008
- Comparison of nasopharyngeal flocked swabs and aspirates for rapid diagnosis of respiratory viruses in childrenJournal of Clinical Virology, 2008
- Validation of Nasopharyngeal Sampling and Culture Techniques for Detection of Streptococcus pneumoniae in Children in KenyaJournal of Clinical Microbiology, 2007
- Comparison of Real-Time PCR Assays with Fluorescent-Antibody Assays for Diagnosis of Respiratory Virus Infections in ChildrenJournal of Clinical Microbiology, 2006