Consolidation as hegemonization: The case of Estonia
- 1 December 2001
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Baltic Studies
- Vol. 32 (4) , 402-420
Abstract
Recent developments in Central and Eastern Europe show that the proper functioning of new political and economic institutions is crucially dependent on their social and cultural environment. Due to this, research has changed its analytical focus from “transition” to “consolidation” of the market economy and representative democracy in the region. A consolidated social order can be defined as one where its central elements have become “the only game in town”. The article treats this process as hegemonization, referring to the theories of Gramsci and Berger and Luckmann. The term “democratic consolidation” itself seems to include a contradiction: How “consolidated” can a political system be in order still to be a democracy? The developments of 1988–1991 in Estonia are analyzed as an ontological and epistemological crisis leading to an abandonment of the old social order, but ending up with no more than vague ideas about the new one. The new political goals which emerged during the 1990s include the prosperity and international security of the Estonian nation. They have been used for delegitimizing the demands of the losers of the transformation — i.e., the Russian-speakers and the economically less well-situated groups. The government's ability to pursue consequent reform policies is based on the fact that not all social cleavages are reflected by institutional politics. As a consequence, people tend to become alienated from it. An activation of non-governmental organizations and Estonia's eventual EU membership may change politics towards a more inclusive direction. At the same time, a post-modernist fragmentation of value systems might push the Western societies themselves towards the laissez-faire economic policies now prevailing in Central and Eastern Europe. (John Buchan, Then Power -House 37)Keywords
This publication has 12 references indexed in Scilit:
- Extraordinary politics in the Polish transitionCommunist and Post-Communist Studies, 1999
- Postsocialism as a Return: Notes on a Discursive StrategyEast European Politics and Societies, 1999
- Reflections on the “Revolutions” of 1989 and AfterEast European Politics and Societies, 1999
- Institutional Design in Post-Communist Societies1998
- The economic transition in the Baltic countriesJournal of Baltic Studies, 1997
- Participation and transition: Can the civil society project survive in Hungary?Journal of Communist Studies and Transition Politics, 1997
- The strange death of ‘civil society’ in post‐communist HungaryJournal of Communist Studies and Transition Politics, 1997
- The Conceptual Travels of Transitologists and Consolidologists: How Far to the East Should They Attempt to Go?Slavic Review, 1994
- Money in Modern CultureTheory, Culture & Society, 1991
- Social Problems, Problematic Situations, and Quasi-TheoriesAmerican Sociological Review, 1973