Trialling a Large Language Model (ChatGPT) in General Practice With the Applied Knowledge Test: Observational Study Demonstrating Opportunities and Limitations in Primary Care
Top Cited Papers
Open Access
- 21 April 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Medical Education
- Vol. 9, e46599
Abstract
Background: Large language models exhibiting human-level performance in specialized tasks are emerging; examples include Generative Pretrained Transformer 3.5, which underlies the processing of ChatGPT. Rigorous trials are required to understand the capabilities of emerging technology, so that innovation can be directed to benefit patients and practitioners. Objective: Here, we evaluated the strengths and weaknesses of ChatGPT in primary care using the Membership of the Royal College of General Practitioners Applied Knowledge Test (AKT) as a medium. Methods: AKT questions were sourced from a web-based question bank and 2 AKT practice papers. In total, 674 unique AKT questions were inputted to ChatGPT, with the model’s answers recorded and compared to correct answers provided by the Royal College of General Practitioners. Each question was inputted twice in separate ChatGPT sessions, with answers on repeated trials compared to gauge consistency. Subject difficulty was gauged by referring to examiners’ reports from 2018 to 2022. Novel explanations from ChatGPT—defined as information provided that was not inputted within the question or multiple answer choices—were recorded. Performance was analyzed with respect to subject, difficulty, question source, and novel model outputs to explore ChatGPT’s strengths and weaknesses. Results: Average overall performance of ChatGPT was 60.17%, which is below the mean passing mark in the last 2 years (70.42%). Accuracy differed between sources (P=.04 and .06). ChatGPT’s performance varied with subject category (P=.02 and .02), but variation did not correlate with difficulty (Spearman ρ=–0.241 and –0.238; P=.19 and .20). The proclivity of ChatGPT to provide novel explanations did not affect accuracy (P>.99 and .23). Conclusions: Large language models are approaching human expert–level performance, although further development is required to match the performance of qualified primary care physicians in the AKT. Validated high-performance models may serve as assistants or autonomous clinical tools to ameliorate the general practice workforce crisis.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Challenge of Integrating eHealth Into Health Care: Systematic Literature Review of the Donabedian Model of Structure, Process, and OutcomeJournal of Medical Internet Research, 2021
- Digital health during COVID-19: lessons from operationalising new models of care in ophthalmologyThe Lancet Digital Health, 2021
- Machine Learning: The Next Paradigm Shift in Medical EducationAcademic Medicine, 2021
- Physicians’ Perceptions of the Use of a Chatbot for Information Seeking: Qualitative StudyJournal of Medical Internet Research, 2020
- The Effectiveness of Artificial Intelligence Conversational Agents in Health Care: Systematic ReviewJournal of Medical Internet Research, 2020
- Should free-text data in electronic medical records be shared for research? A citizens’ jury study in the UKJournal of Medical Ethics, 2020
- A guide to deep learning in healthcareNature Medicine, 2019
- General practice work and workforce: Interdependencies between demand, supply and qualityAustralian Journal of General Practice, 2018
- Shortage of general practitioners in the NHSBMJ, 2017
- Addressing the crisis of GP recruitment and retention: a systematic reviewBritish Journal of General Practice, 2017