Walk your path, speak the truth: the balance between sustainability commitment and communication
- 28 July 2026
- journal article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Journal of Business Strategy
- p. 1-22
Abstract
Purpose: This study aims to examine how consumers perceive and interpret corporate sustainability signals in light of the alignment between firms’ actual sustainability commitment and their sustainability communication. Design/methodology/approach: Grounded in legitimacy theory and signaling theory, this exploratory qualitative study uses in-depth interviews with Brazilian consumers to examine how they interpret sustainability signals across various organizational commitment and communication configurations, as conceptualized in the transparency matrix. Findings: Interview participants judge corporate sustainability by the coherence between what firms do and what they claim. The findings clarify how participants define sustainability commitment and show that they strongly penalize opaque companies, while viewing translucent companies more ambivalently. They also accept incremental progress and legitimize “shades of transparency,” where firms coherently disclose partial but authentic efforts. Research limitations/implications: As the study is exploratory and conducted in a single national context, with participants predominantly well-educated, the findings should be interpreted cautiously. Practical implications: The findings guide managers in aligning sustainability communication with actual commitment and organizational maturity. Acknowledging limits and trade-offs reduces perceptions of greenwashing, builds stakeholder trust and strengthens legitimacy, even when progress is incremental. Originality/value: The study extends the transparency matrix by introducing an intermediate configuration, labeled “shades of transparency,” which captures companies that communicate partial but genuine sustainability efforts in alignment with their organizational maturity. This reconceptualization moves beyond dichotomous classifications, offering a more nuanced framework to understand coherence as a driver of legitimacy.Keywords
This publication has 47 references indexed in Scilit:
- Uncovering the Evolution of Brand Transparency in Corporate Social Responsibility: A Holistic PerspectiveCorporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management, 2025
- The Legitimacy–Commitment Paradox in Corporate Sustainability Strategy FormulationBusiness Strategy and the Environment, 2025
- Do not walk into darkness in greenhushing: A cross‐cultural study on why Chinese and South Korean corporations engage in greenhushing behaviorBUSINESS STRATEGY & DEVELOPMENT, 2024
- Toward a view of integrating corporate sustainability into strategy: A systematic literature reviewCorporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management, 2023
- The influence of greenwashing practices on brand attitude: A multidimensional consumer analysis in GermanyBusiness Strategy and the Environment, 2023
- Why companies might under‐communicate their efforts for sustainable development and what can be done?Business Strategy and the Environment, 2022
- Commitment to Sustainability in Small and Medium‐Sized Enterprises: The Influence of Strategic Orientations and Management ValuesBusiness Strategy and the Environment, 2015
- Corporate sustainability strategies: sustainability profiles and maturity levelsSustainable Development, 2010
- Evolving sustainably: a longitudinal study of corporate sustainable developmentStrategic Management Journal, 2004
- Beyond the business case for corporate sustainabilityBusiness Strategy and the Environment, 2002