Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate first-trimester clinical content, quality, functionality, and visible privacy and security features of freely available pregnancy applications (apps) in the United Kingdom.METHODS: A three-stage pre-defined pregnancy app evaluation was conducted. Stage 1: Pregnancy apps were identified via Google Search, ChatGPT, the Apple App Store, and Google Play. 507 apps were identified and 72 met inclusion criteria. Stage 2: A researcher-developed, 65-item First Trimester Content Checklist, mapped to NICE, NHS and RCOG guidance, was applied to all 72 apps which were then categorised as Tier A (≥75%), B (55–74%), C (35–54%), or D (<35%) depending on their Percentage Coverage Score. Stage 3: Apps meeting Tier A or B underwent evaluation using the Mobile App Rating Scale (MARS), the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics Functionality Framework, and a researcher-developed Privacy and Security Checklist.RESULTS: Median first-trimester content coverage across the 72 apps was low at 18.1% (IQR 10.8–32.5). Most apps (n=56, 77.8%) were classified as Tier D and only six (8.3%) achieved Tier A/B. Median domain coverage was highest for Symptoms & Red Flags (27.8%) and lowest for Inclusivity (0%; IQR 0–7.1%). Among the six highest-scoring apps, MARS scores ranged from 3.52 to 4.59, IMS scores from 4 to 8 of 11, and privacy and security scores from 8 to 9 of 11.CONCLUSIONS: Most freely available UK pregnancy apps provided limited first trimester information, and important gaps remained even among the highest-scoring apps, particularly in inclusivity. As the first trimester is a period of limited clinical contact and high information need, the availability of poorly regulated pregnancy apps may expose patients to unsafe guidance or incorrect information. These findings highlight the need for improved regulation of pregnancy apps.