The Complexity of Jokes Is Limited by Cognitive Constraints on Mentalizing
- 23 November 2015
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Human Nature
- Vol. 27 (2) , 130-140
Abstract
Although laughter is probably of deep evolutionary origin, the telling of jokes, being language-based, is likely to be of more recent origin within the human lineage. In language-based communication, speaker and listener are engaged in a process of mutually understanding each other’s intentions (mindstates), with a conversation minimally requiring three orders of intentionality. Mentalizing is cognitively more demanding than non-mentalizing cognition, and there is a well-attested limit at five orders in the levels of intentionality at which normal adult humans can work. Verbal jokes commonly involve commentary on the mindstates of third parties, and each such mindstate adds an additional level of intentionality and its corresponding cognitive load. We determined the number of mentalizing levels in a sample of jokes told by well-known professional comedians and show that most jokes involve either three or five orders of intentionality on the part of the comedian, depending on whether or not the joke involves other individuals’ mindstates. Within this limit there is a positive correlation between increasing levels of intentionality and subjective ratings of how funny the jokes are. The quality of jokes appears to peak when they include five or six levels of intentionality, which suggests that audiences appreciate higher mentalizing complexity whilst working within their natural cognitive constraints.Keywords
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- Sharing a joke: The effects of a similar sense of humor on affiliation and altruismEvolution and Human Behavior, 2013
- Perception of Contrariety in JokesDiscourse Processes, 2012
- Social laughter is correlated with an elevated pain thresholdProceedings Of The Royal Society B-Biological Sciences, 2011
- Orbital prefrontal cortex volume correlates with social cognitive competenceNeuropsychologia, 2010
- Reconstructing the Evolution of Laughter in Great Apes and HumansCurrent Biology, 2009
- The encryption theory of humor: A knowledge-based mechanism of honest signalingJournal of Evolutionary Psychology, 2008
- Production and appreciation of humor as sexually selected traitsEvolution and Human Behavior, 2006
- Theory‐of‐mind deficits and causal attributionsBritish Journal of Psychology, 1998
- Human conversational behaviorHuman Nature, 1997
- Strangers meet: Laughter and nonverbal signs of interest in opposite-sex encountersJournal of Nonverbal Behavior, 1990