Why Are Those Lines Placed Where They Are?: An Investigation of Soil Map Recompilation Methods

Authors:

Abstract
Recompilation of soil maps to acceptable base maps is currently a major activity for soil scientists. The widespread use of Geographic Information Systems (GIS) has accelerated this activity in the past 5 to 10 yr with the emphasis on soil survey updates and SSUR‐GO development. This study was initiated to evaluate methods of recompilation common to the region and determine the effect of base map, and method on the resulting placement of recompiled soil lines by soil scientists. Three common recompilation procedures were utilized. Two used enlarged U.S. Geological Service (USGS) topographic quadrangles as a base map and one used a USGS orthophoto as a base. Enlarged soil film transparencies were used for two of the procedures and a projected image of a soil map for the other. Five different soil scientists performed the recompilation. Data was digitized and GIS used to analyze, summarize and visualize the data. Results from Chi‐Square analysis and Tukey' Multiple Comparison test indicated no distinct relationship between methods. As was expected, repeatability among soil scientists increased as map complexity decreased.

This publication has 3 references indexed in Scilit: