Spectrum of Response Styles in a Religious-Orthodox Community to Civilian Disasters: The Responses of the Haredi Community to the Meron Crowd Crush (2021) as a Case Study
Open Access
Abstract
Over the past few decades the Haredi community has been expanding and it includes a diversity of groups characterized by wide margins, therefore it may be considered an imagined community. On Lag Ba’Omer 2021, 45 people died, and over 150 were injured in the Meron Crowd Crush, most of them from the diverse Haredi community in Israel. Coping with disasters in a religious community includes a religious-faith level, and a social level. In this study, we will examine the response styles to a disaster in the Haredi community, as a case study of religious communities coping with a civilian disaster. This study will assist in understanding the community’s narrative, and the place of the community in coping with a disaster. The study uses the qualitative-constructivist method and applies a categorical analysis of 1146 verbal responses to an internet survey that was conducted subsequent to the disaster. We propose a theoretical-categorical model that divides the responses into five pairs of categories: Emotional, Religious, Spiritual-Transcendental, Social, and Civil responses, each pair divided into past and future. Emotional responses: expressing grief and mourning (past), or paralysis, anxiety, and instability, (future); Religious responses: search for a religious reason (past), or a call for religious strengthening (future); Spiritual-Transcendent responses: dealing with questions of faith (past), or viewing the disaster as a transcendent message, and seeking spiritual comfort (future); Social-Spiritual responses: attributing the disaster to collective punishment due to ‘corruption’ (past), or recommendations for ‘correction’ of the social world (future); Civil responses: including searching for deficiencies, blaming entities (past), or suggestions for improvements and correction of deficiencies (future). We discussed a spectrum of response styles, while distinguishing between responses that are concerned with finding a reason or explanation for the disaster (past), and those who wish to draw a conclusion (future). Furthermore, social injustices are seen as religious offenses that led to the disaster. That is, it is a religious soul-searching that deals, less with traditional offenses and more with social injustices. We also discussed the volume of the different responses: In the emotional reactions and civil reactions, the Past Category is larger than the Future, whereas in the religious and spiritual responses, the Future categories are larger. This finding may symbolize a tendency to channel the pain in a positive way to a practical and active direction. Religious actions provide a sense of agency and self-efficacy. At last, we noticed that the disaster led to the strengthening of the community and sense of community, despite its size and diversity; as well, we suggested that the findings regarding religious-orthodox communities and their coping with disasters can be inferred.Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- Perceived Discrimination and Well-Being Among the Ultra-Orthodox in Israel: The Mediating Role of Group IdentityJournal of Cross-Cultural Psychology, 2017
- Sustainable Communities, Sustainable Development2012
- Further Thoughts on Religion and ModernitySociety, 2012
- Reactions to Terror Attacks in Ultra-Orthodox Jews: The Cost of Maintaining Strict IdentityPsychiatry, 2010
- Religion as a Meaning‐Making Framework in Coping with Life StressJournal of Social Issues, 2005
- Acute and chronic distress and posstraumatic stress disorder as a function of responsibility for serious motor vehicle accidents.Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 1997
- The length of the slits and the spread of luxury: Reconstructing the subordination of ultra-Orthodox jewish women through the patriarchy of men scholarsSex Roles, 1993
- Grounded Theory and Organizational ResearchThe Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 1986
- Sense of community: A definition and theoryJournal of Community Psychology, 1986
- Public Self and Private Self1986