Abstract
First, the design of the two studies is quite different. Devulapalli et al. 1 carried out a longitudinal observational study of a population sample in which young children who were prescribed ICS for “recurrent bronchial obstruction” (undefined) were compared with untreated symptomatic and symptom-free groups. Although the design is justified as being “based upon … real life”, it suffers from the shortfall that an independent effect of ICS on functional outcome cannot be deduced from the results presented. At best, it is possible to conclude that both treated and untreated young children with recurrent bronchial obstruction appear functionally to return towards normal by 2 yrs of age. Multivariate analysis might have added strength to the assumption that this process was indeed related in someway to ICS therapy, rather than being simply a reflection of the natural history of the disorder.

This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit: