Preemption in Tobacco Control: A Framework for Other Areas of Public Health
Authors:
- 1 March 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Public Health Association in American Journal of Public Health
- Vol. 110 (3) , 345-350
Abstract
Preemption—when a higher level of government limits the authority of a lower level to enact new policies—has been devastating to tobacco control. We developed a preemption framework based on this experience for anticipating and responding to the possibility of preemption in other public health areas. We analyzed peer-reviewed literature, reports, and government documents pertaining to tobacco control preemption. We triangulated data and thematically analyzed them.Since the 1980s, tobacco companies have attempted to secure state preemption through front groups, lobbying key policymakers, inserting preemption into other legislation, and issuing legal threats and challenges. The tobacco control community responded by creating awareness of preemption through media advocacy, educating policymakers, mobilizing national collaborations, and expanding networks with the legal community. Ten of the 25 state smoke-free preemption laws have been fully repealed. Repeal, however, took an average of 11 years.State preemption has been detrimental to tobacco control by dividing the health community, weakening local authority, chilling public education and debate, and slowing local policy diffusion. Health scholars, advocates, and policymakers should use the framework to anticipate and prevent industry use of preemption in other public health areas.Keywords
This publication has 34 references indexed in Scilit:
- Assessing the Impact of Federal and State Preemption in Public HealthJournal of Public Health Management & Practice, 2013
- The Impact of State Preemption of Local Smoking Restrictions on Public Health Protections and Changes in Social NormsJournal of Environmental and Public Health, 2012
- Innovative Legal Approaches to Address ObesityThe Milbank Quarterly, 2009
- Preemption of Local Smoke-Free Air Ordinances: The Implications of Judicial Opinions for Meeting National Health ObjectivesJournal of Law, Medicine & Ethics, 2008
- Preemption and the Obesity Epidemic: State and Local Menu Labeling Laws and the Nutrition Labeling and Education ActJournal of Law, Medicine & Ethics, 2008
- The Impact of Clean Indoor Air Exemptions and Preemption Policies on the Prevalence of a Tobacco-Specific Lung Carcinogen Among Nonsmoking Bar and Restaurant WorkersAmerican Journal of Public Health, 2007
- Support for and reported compliance with smoke-free restaurants and bars by smokers in four countries: findings from the International Tobacco Control (ITC) Four Country SurveyTobacco Control, 2006
- Tobacco industry litigation to deter local public health ordinances: the industry usually loses in court: Table 1Tobacco Control, 2004
- Application of a rating system to state clean indoor air laws (USA)Tobacco Control, 2002
- Cancer converts tobacco lobbyist: Victor L. Crawford goes on the record. Interview by Andrew A. Skolnick1995