Factors affecting the (in)accuracy of mammalian mesocarnivore scat identification in South‐western Europe
Open Access
- 13 November 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Zoology
- Vol. 289 (4) , 243-250
Abstract
Research on terrestrial carnivore ecology frequently relies on scat identification and analysis. However, species assignment is commonly based on scat morphology. Potential errors in scat identification are rarely accounted for and might contribute to substantial bias of the final results. Using molecular methods, we evaluate the accuracy of species identification based on morphological characteristics of mammalian mesocarnivore scats collected in two areas in the Iberian Peninsula. Our results revealed that error rates in species assignment of scats based on morphology were highly variable, ranging from 14%, for putative red fox Vulpes vulpes samples, to 88%, for putative wildcats Felis silvestris. The developed models revealed that putative species, season, study area and target species abundance are among the factors involved in identification accuracy. However, the low variability explained suggests that unaccounted factors also had significant effects on accuracy rates. The error rates in scat species assignment constitute a potential source of bias in ecological studies, with serious consequences for the management of threatened species, as unrealistic estimates of status and distribution are prone to occur. Our results suggest that scat identification accuracy rates are circumstance‐specific and therefore should not be transferred or extrapolated. We suggest that scat‐based studies should implement measures (molecular or others) that allow researchers to determine their own circumstance‐specific error rates in scat identification, which should be incorporated in subsequent analyses, ensuring reliable ecological inferences.Keywords
Funding Information
- Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia (SFRH/BD/37795/2007)
- Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation and EU-FEDER
This publication has 47 references indexed in Scilit:
- Improving occupancy estimation when two types of observational error occur: non-detection and species misidentificationEcology, 2011
- The accuracy of scat identification in distribution surveys: American mink, Neovison vison, in the northern highlands of ScotlandEuropean Journal of Wildlife Research, 2009
- Species identification using a small nuclear gene fragment: application to sympatric wild carnivores from South-western EuropeConservation Genetics, 2009
- Red foxes (Vulpes vulpes) use rabbit (Oryctolagus cuniculus) scent marks as territorial marking sitesJournal of Ethology, 2008
- Camera Trapping of Carnivores: Trap Success Among Camera Types and Across Species, and Habitat Selection by Species, on Salt Pond Mountain, Giles County, VirginiaNortheastern Naturalist, 2008
- Species-specific mitochondrial DNA markers for identification of non-invasive samples from sympatric carnivores in the Iberian PeninsulaConservation Genetics, 2007
- Surveying carnivores at large spatial scales: a comparison of four broad-applied methodsBiodiversity and Conservation, 2006
- Noninvasive population genetics: a review of sample source, diet, fragment length and microsatellite motif effects on amplification success and genotyping error ratesConservation Genetics, 2006
- DIETARY ANALYSIS FROM FECAL SAMPLES: HOW MANY SCATS ARE ENOUGH?Journal of Mammalogy, 2005
- CLUSTAL W: improving the sensitivity of progressive multiple sequence alignment through sequence weighting, position-specific gap penalties and weight matrix choiceNucleic Acids Research, 1994