We have to set the bar higher: towards consumer leadership, beyond engagement or involvement
Author:
- 5 May 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by CSIRO Publishing in Australian Health Review
- Vol. 46 (4) , 509-512
Abstract
Understanding of the benefits of consumer-led health policy, practice, research and education has been developing for decades. However, barriers to genuine, non-tokenistic consumer leadership remain across the health sector. While recent calls to align Australian consumer engagement practices with those in the UK and elsewhere may sound progressive, doing so would be problematic for three reasons. First, Australia has been at the forefront of consumer leadership scholarship and advocacy for decades, and we should not ignore the work consumers and allies have done in improving our health systems. Second, although there have been positive outcomes from consumer engagement and inclusion practices (as often required in other jurisdictions), they are open to tokenism and continue to position consumers’ experiential expertise as ‘lesser’ compared to other health sector stakeholders’ knowledge. Last, compared to consumer leadership, engagement or inclusion are ‘lower bars’ for health professionals to aim for. If we settle for engagement or inclusion in cases where consumer leadership would have been possible, then we lose not only our position at the forefront of consumer leadership, but also the expertise of consumers. Three propositions are provided: (1) we should support consumer-led development policy for consumer leadership in health, (2) we should ensure consumer leadership in oversight over as well as conduct of health and medical research, (3) we should encourage honest claims about the extent to which projects or initiatives are led by or with consumers.Keywords
This publication has 12 references indexed in Scilit:
- Building collaborative leadership: A qualitative evaluation of the Australian Collaborative Pairs trialHealth & Social Care in the Community, 2022
- Drawing straight lines along blurred boundaries: qualitative research, patient and public involvement in medical research, co-production and co-designEvidence & Policy, 2019
- ‘Not in the room, but the doctors were’: an Australian story-completion study about consumer representationHealth Promotion International, 2019
- Response to Commentary by von Peter to Happell, Brenda, & Scholz, Brett (2018). Doing what we can, but knowing our place: Being an ally to promote consumer leadership in mental health. International Journal of Mental Health Nursing, 27(1), 440–447International Journal of Mental Health Nursing, 2018
- “Not an afterthought”: Power imbalances in systemic partnerships between health service providers and consumers in a hospital settingHealth Policy, 2018
- Rhetoric of representation: the disempowerment and empowerment of consumer leadersHealth Promotion International, 2017
- Breaking through the Glass Ceiling: Consumers in Mental Health Organisations' HierarchiesIssues in Mental Health Nursing, 2017
- Improving exchange with consumers within mental health organizations: Recognizing mental ill health experience as a ‘sneaky, special degree’International Journal of Mental Health Nursing, 2017
- Service user involvement in research may lead to contrary rather than collaborative accounts: findings from a qualitative palliative care studyJournal of Advanced Nursing, 2015
- The Role of the Consumer in the Leadership and Management of Mental Health ServicesAustralasian Psychiatry, 2005