Model Dependency in the Analysis of Women's Electoral Success
Open Access
- 4 November 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Politics & Gender
- Vol. 17 (2) , 349-363
Abstract
Maciej Górecki provides a detailed and interesting discussion of our analysis regarding women's electoral success in the Polish open-list proportional representation (PR) system and the impact of a gender quota implemented in 2011. In essence, he claims that it remains an open question whether the gender quota had a ‘paradoxical’ effect (i.e., whether the introduction of the gender quota had a negative impact on female candidates) due to ‘debatable’ methodological choices in our analysis. In this article, we respond to Górecki's critique. First, we demonstrate that we do not necessarily disagree on the paradoxical impact of the gender quota but rather on the strength of the paradoxical effect. Second, we discuss some drawbacks of using the raw number of votes cast for a candidate as the dependent variable. Finally, we respond to the critique of including the ballot position in the regression model. We emphasize that even if one agrees with Górecki's critique that the ballot position is endogenous, excluding this variable leads to a severely misspecified model that does not allow one to reliably identify the effect of gender.Keywords
This publication has 11 references indexed in Scilit:
- Cue-Taking, Satisficing, or Both? Quasi-experimental Evidence for Ballot Position EffectsPolitical Behavior, 2018
- Do Women Get Fewer Votes? No.Canadian Journal of Political Science, 2018
- The Ties That Double Bind: Social Roles and Women's Underrepresentation in PoliticsAmerican Political Science Review, 2018
- Ineffective and Counterproductive? The Impact of Gender Quotas in Open-List Proportional Representation SystemsPolitics & Gender, 2017
- Votes for Women: Electoral Systems and Support for Female CandidatesPolitics & Gender, 2017
- Are populist parties fostering women’s political representation in Poland? A comment on Kostadinova and MikulskaParty Politics, 2016
- Ballot Position Effects Under Compulsory and Optional Preferential-List PR Electoral SystemsPolitical Behavior, 2014
- Gender quotas, candidate background and the election of women: A paradox of gender quotas in open-list proportional representation systemsElectoral Studies, 2014
- When There's No Easy Way Out: Electoral Law Reform and Ballot Position Effects in the 2011 Hamburg State ElectionsGerman Politics, 2014
- Electoral contexts that assist voter coordination: Ballot position effects in PolandElectoral Studies, 2014