Moral Luck and the Law
Author:
- 6 January 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Philosophy Compass
- Vol. 5 (1) , 42-54
Abstract
Is there a difference in moral blameworthiness between a murderer and an attempted murderer? Should there be a legal difference between them? These questions are particular instances of the question of moral luck and legal luck (respectively). In this paper, I survey and explain the main argumentative moves within the general philosophical discussion of moral luck. I then discuss legal luck, and the different ways in which this discussion may be related to that of moral luck.Keywords
This publication has 38 references indexed in Scilit:
- Wouldn't It Be Nice If p, Therefore, p (for a moral p)Utilitas, 2009
- Luck Between Morality, Law, and JusticeTheoretical Inquiries in Law, 2007
- Luck and IdentityTheoretical Inquiries in Law, 2007
- Tossing the Rotten Thing Out: Eliminating Bad Reasons not to Solve the Problem of Moral LuckPhilosophy, 2005
- Morality, Moral Luck and Responsibility2005
- There Is No DoorThe Journal of Philosophy, 2004
- The Economics of the Law of Criminal Attempts: A Victim-Centered PerspectiveUniversity of Pennsylvania Law Review, 1996
- Auctions, lotteries, and the punishment of attemptsLaw and Philosophy, 1990
- Why attempts deserve less punishment than complete crimesLaw and Philosophy, 1986
- Nagel, Williams, and moral luckAnalysis, 1983