An Experimental Comparison of Simulation Tools for Fixed-Block and Moving-Block Train Control Systems
Open Access
- 16 October 2026
- book chapter
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 166-184
Abstract
The growing interest in moving-block train control systems, driven by the deployment of the European Train Control System (ETCS) Level 3 and Communications-Based Train Control (CBTC) technologies, has intensified the need for reliable and versatile simulation tools capable of accurately representing both legacy fixed-block and next-generation moving-block signalling architectures. This paper presents an experimental comparison of three railway simulation platforms—OpenTrack, PoliSim, and SUMO—evaluated across heterogeneous infrastructure scenarios encompassing high-speed and regional railway lines. The assessment examines each tool’s capacity to model train dynamics, headway constraints, capacity utilisation, and signalling logic under both fixed-block and moving-block operational regimes. A structured evaluation framework is proposed, considering key dimensions such as modelling accuracy, input data requirements, computational performance, interoperability, and suitability for different planning contexts. Results reveal significant differences in the representational capabilities and operational scope of the three simulators, highlighting trade-offs between usability and technical depth.Keywords
This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit:
- A Railway Network Dataset Incorporating Multi-Type Train Operation Records and Train SchedulingScientific Data, 2025
- Quantitative Dependability Evaluation of Train Control Systems in Presence of Uncertainty: A Systematic Literature Review2025
- A Modular Simulation Tool for Fixed Block and Moving Block Railway Signalling SystemsSSRN Electronic Journal, 2024
- Connected or Autonomous Trains?2019
- Microscopic Traffic Simulation using SUMO2018
- Energetic optimization of regenerative braking for high speed railway systemsEnergy Conversion and Management, 2016
- Simulation model of speed control for the moving-block systems under ERTMS Level 32016
- Towards modeling and evaluation of ETCS real-time communication and operationJournal of Systems and Software, 2005