In the current context of socio-economic transformations, the issue of determining the criteria and indicators of effectiveness in the implementation of construction and investment projects has become particularly relevant. The construction sector is characterized by high capital intensity, long investment cycles, and the multifactorial influence of external and internal risks. Therefore, traditional evaluation approaches, primarily focused on financial and economic indicators, are gradually losing their universality and require adaptation to new conditions. In today’s investment and construction environment, effectiveness should be viewed as a complex category encompassing financial returns, social impact, environmental sustainability, risk exposure, implementation speed, innovativeness, and digital integration. The article argues that defining effectiveness criteria is not only a techno-economic task but also a strategic process that forms the basis for resource management, risk minimization, and sustainable development. Special attention is given to the development of indicators that allow for the quantitative assessment of project performance and its alignment with predetermined strategic objectives. Emphasis is placed on the importance of integrating modern digital technologies—BIM, ERP, Big Data, and analytical management dashboards—into the evaluation process, which ensures transparency, accuracy, and timeliness in decision-making.