Alter-Globalism as Counter-Hegemony: Evaluating the ‘postmodern Prince’
- 17 December 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Globalizations
- Vol. 6 (4) , 483-498
Abstract
This article seeks to provide a critical analysis of the alter-globalisation movement as a potential ‘postmodern Prince’ as advanced by Stephen Gill. The article proposes that the social forces aligned under the rubric of alter-globalism have always had intractable difficulties articulating a postmodern Prince, and that in contrast to Gill's appropriation of Gramsci, these difficulties can be usefully understood through a reading of Gramsci which is attentive to the problems of collective political action. Recent debate among key participants at the World Social Forum (WSF) is used as a case study for analysing the possibility of formulating a common master-frame or strategy for social transformation. It is at the WSF that the problems of articulating a postmodern Prince have been most clearly confronted. It is shown that the weaknesses of alter-globalism can be understood, pace Gill, through Gramsci's own theory of social transformation as evinced in the modern Prince. This underlines the need for further investigation of the agents of progressive politics in an era of global social transformation. Este artículo busca proveer un análisis crítico a la propuesta de Stephen Gill, sobre el movimiento alter-globalización como un potencial ‘Príncipe posmoderno’. El artículo propone que las fuerzas sociales alineadas bajo la rúbrica del alter-globalismo han tenido siempre dificultades intratables en plantear a un Príncipe posmoderno y que en contraste con Gil y su apropiación de Gramsci, estas dificultades pueden entenderse útilmente a través de una lectura de Gramsci, quien está atento a los problemas de acción colectiva política. Un debate reciente entre los participantes principales al Foro Social Mundial, (FSM) se ha usado como un estudio de caso para analizar la posibilidad de formular un marco maestro o estrategia para una transformación social. En el FSM, es donde más claramente se han confrontado los problemas de plantear a un Príncipe posmoderno. Se ha indicado que las debilidades del alter-globalismo se pueden entender, con el respeto a la opinión de Gill, a través de la propia teoría de Gramsci sobre la transformación social como se evidencia en el Príncipe moderno. Esto enfatiza la necesidad de una mayor investigación de los agentes de una política progresiva en una era de transformación social global.Keywords
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Myth of the Multitude: The Endogenous Demise of Alter-globalist PoliticsGlobal Society, 2008
- Mapping the MovementDevelopment, 2005
- Social Forums, Social Movements and Social Change: A Response to Peter Marcuse on the Subject of the World Social ForumInternational Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 2005
- A critical theory route to hegemony, world order and historical change: neo-Gramscian perspectives in International RelationsCapital & Class, 2004
- Global Governance and the Critical PublicRhetoric and Public Affairs, 2003
- Toward a Postmodern Prince? The Battle in Seattle as a Moment in the New Politics of GlobalisationMillennium: Journal of International Studies, 2000
- (Re-)Engaging Gramsci: a response to Germain and KennyReview of International Studies, 1998
- Understanding IR: understanding GramsciReview of International Studies, 1998
- International political economy in the age of open MarxismReview of International Political Economy, 1994
- Gramsci and global politics: towards a post-hegemonic research agenda1993