To tell the truth: on scientific counterpublics
Author:
- 18 March 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Public Understanding of Science
- Vol. 20 (5) , 627-641
Abstract
Research in the public understanding of science for and against the public deficit model often is based on assumptions of individualism and lay knowledge. That approach to the public is contrasted with a second and third concept of the public. Subordinate networks in diverse social fields can form counterpublics when they claim to represent the general public benefit better than the official constructions of the public and public interest that are articulated by the spokespersons of the dominant agents of the respective social fields. Among the counterpublics are those formed by subordinate networks in the scientific field. Two cases of scientific counterpublics, their relations with subordinate networks in other social fields, and their alternative concepts of public good, are explored in an effort to develop a broader understanding of the public and publics. Two policy implications, targeted funding pools and the “dissensus conference,” are discussed as possible policy innovations that could be developed in addition to deliberative and consultative approaches such as the consensus conference.Keywords
This publication has 27 references indexed in Scilit:
- Evolving scientific research governance in Australia: a case study of engaging interested publics in nanotechnology researchPublic Understanding of Science, 2009
- Building citizen capacities for participation in nanotechnology decision-making: the democratic virtues of the consensus Conference modelPublic Understanding of Science, 2008
- Accounting for expertise: Wynne and the autonomy of the lay public actorPublic Understanding of Science, 2008
- Elephants in the rooms where publics encounter “science”?: A response to Darrin Durant, “Accounting for expertise: Wynne and the autonomy of the lay public”Public Understanding of Science, 2008
- Against the neoliberal steamroller? The Biosafety Protocol and the social regulation of agricultural biotechnologiesAgriculture and Human Values, 2007
- Publics and CounterpublicsPublic Culture, 2002
- Economic Restructuring and the Restructuring of Economic Development Practice: A New York Perspective, 1985-1995Economic Development Quarterly, 1996
- Import Substitution and Local Economic DevelopmentEconomic Development Quarterly, 1993
- Captives of Controversy: The Myth of the Neutral Social Researcher in Contemporary Scientific ControversiesScience, Technology, & Human Values, 1990
- Medical and Biological Constraints: Early Research on Variation in BacteriologySocial Studies of Science, 1987