Redefining Quality in Medical Education Research: A Consumer's View
Authors:
- Gail M. SullivanGSGail M. Sullivan
- Deborah SimpsonDSDeborah Simpson
- David A. CookDCDavid A. Cook
- Nicole M. DeIorioNDNicole M. DeIorio
- Kathryn AndolsekKAKathryn Andolsek
- Lawrence OpasLOLawrence Opas
- Ingrid PhilibertIPIngrid Philibert
- Lalena M. YarrisLYLalena M. Yarris
- 1 September 2014
- journal article
- Published by Journal of Graduate Medical Education in Journal of Graduate Medical Education
- Vol. 6 (3) , 424-429
Abstract
Background: Despite an explosion of medical education research and publications, it is not known how medical educator consumers decide what to read or apply in their practice. Objective: To determine how consumers of medical education research define quality and value. Methods: Journal of Graduate Medical Education editors performed a literature search to identify articles on medical education research quality published between 2000 and 2013, surveyed medical educators for their criteria for judging quality, and led a consensus-building workshop at a 2013 Association of American Medical Colleges meeting to further explore how users defined quality in education research. The workshop used standard consensus-building techniques to reach concept saturation. Attendees then voted for the 3 concepts they valued most in medical education research. Results: The 110 survey responses generated a list of 37 overlapping features in 10 categories considered important aspects of quality. The literature search yielded 27 articles, including quality indexes, systematic and narrative reviews, and commentaries. Thirty-two participants, 12 facilitators, and 1 expert observer attended the workshop. Participants endorsed the following features of education research as being most valuable: (1) provocative, novel, or challenged established thinking; (2) adhered to sound research principles; (3) relevant to practice, role, or needs; (4) feasible, practical application in real-world settings; and (5) connection to a conceptual framework. Conclusions: Medical educators placed high value on rigorous methods and conceptual frameworks, consistent with published quality indexes. They also valued innovative or provocative work, feasibility, and applicability to their setting. End-user opinions of quality may illuminate how educators translate knowledge into practice.Keywords
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- Method and reporting quality in health professions education research: a systematic reviewMedical Education, 2011
- A critical review of simulation‐based medical education research: 2003–2009Medical Education, 2009
- Proposed Standards for Medical Education Submissions to the Journal of General Internal MedicineJournal of General Internal Medicine, 2008
- Predictive Validity Evidence for Medical Education Research Study Quality Instrument Scores: Quality of Submissions to JGIM’s Medical Education Special IssueJournal of General Internal Medicine, 2008
- Quality of reporting of experimental studies in medical education: a systematic reviewMedical Education, 2007
- Early practical experience and the social responsiveness of clinical education: systematic reviewBMJ, 2005
- Appraising qualitative research articles in medicine and medical educationMedical Teacher, 2005
- Reasons Reviewers Reject and Accept ManuscriptsAcademic Medicine, 2001
- BEME Guide No. 1: Best Evidence Medical EducationMedical Teacher, 1999
- Do you know?Medical Teacher, 1999