On the limits of Kagan’s impulsive reflective distinction
Authors:
Open Access
- 1 May 1976
- journal article
- Published by Springer Nature in Memory & Cognition
- Vol. 4 (3) , 272-276
Abstract
A logical analysis is made of the Matching Familiar Figures (MFF) Test on the basis of which children have been classified as "impulsive" or "reflective." The reflective strategy is implicitly preferred to the impulsive because the reflective child makes fewer errors though generally taking longer to make his first response. We show that the test allows the choice of a number of "game plans" and speed-accuracy tradeoffs which in practice may not be very different. Error rates may not indicate perceptual sensitivity, in any case, since sensitivity and response factors may be confounded in the error rate. Using a visual running-memory-span task to avoid the inherent difficulties of the MFF test, we found that children previously classified on the basis of that test as impulsive or reflective did not differ in recognition accuracy but did differ in response bias and response latency. Accuracy and bias are estimated by way of Luce's choice theory (Luce, 1963), and the results are discussed in those terms.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Visual facilitation of auditory localization in schoolchildren: A signal detection analysisPerception & Psychophysics, 1975
- A comparison of binary and rating techniques in the signal detection analysis of recognition memoryActa Psychologica, 1975
- Speed-accuracy tradeoff models for auditory detection with deadlinesActa Psychologica, 1974
- Training Impulsive Children in the Use of More Efficient Scanning TechniquesChild Development, 1974
- Response bias in the recognition of pictures and names by children.Journal of Experimental Psychology, 1974
- The Separation of Bias and Sensitivity in Multiple-Choice TasksPerception, 1973
- Recognition Memory in Reflective and Impulsive Preschool ChildrenChild Development, 1973
- Response latency models for signal detection.Psychological Review, 1973
- Reflection-impulsivity: The generality and dynamics of conceptual tempo.Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 1966
- Retention of information under conditions approaching a steady state.Journal of Experimental Psychology, 1961