Comparative Cradle-to-Grave Life Cycle Assessment of Low and Mid-Rise Mass Timber Buildings with Equivalent Structural Steel Alternatives
Open Access
- 19 March 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Sustainability
- Vol. 13 (6) , 3401
Abstract
The objective of this paper was to quantify and compare the environmental impacts associated with alternative designs of typical North American low and mid-rise buildings. Two scenarios were considered: a traditional structural steel frame or an all-wood mass timber design, utilizing engineered wood products for both gravity and lateral load resistance. The boundary of the quantitative analysis was cradle-to-grave with considerations taken to discuss end-of-life and material reuse scenarios. The TRACI methodology was followed to conduct a Life Cycle Impact Assessment (LCIA) analysis that translates building quantities to environmental impact indicators using the Athena Impact Estimator for Buildings Life Cycle analysis software tool and Athena’s Life Cycle Inventory database. The results of the analysis show that mass timber buildings have an advantage with respect to several environmental impact categories, including eutrophication potential, human health particulate, and global warming potential where a 31% to 41% reduction was found from mass timber to steel designs, neglecting potential carbon sequestration benefits from the timber products. However, it was also found that the steel buildings have a lower impact with respect to the environmental impact categories of smog potential, acidification potential, and ozone depletion potential, where a 48% to 58% reduction was found from the steel to the mass timber building designs.Keywords
Funding Information
- American Institute of Steel Construction (N/A)
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- Environmental benefits of using hybrid CLT structure in midrise non-residential construction: An LCA based comparative case study in the U.S. Pacific NorthwestJournal of Building Engineering, 2019
- Feasibility Study of Mass-Timber Cores for the UBC Tall Wood BuildingBuildings, 2018
- A detailed analysis of the embodied energy and carbon emissions of steel-construction residential buildings in ChinaEnergy and Buildings, 2016
- A Comparative Cradle-to-Gate Life Cycle Assessment of Mid-Rise Office Building Construction Alternatives: Laminated Timber or Reinforced ConcreteBuildings, 2012
- Evaluation of whole life cycle assessment for heritage buildings in AustraliaBuilding and Environment, 2012
- Life cycle energy analysis of buildings: An overviewEnergy and Buildings, 2010
- Life cycle primary energy use and carbon emission of an eight-storey wood-framed apartment buildingEnergy and Buildings, 2010
- Environmental Impacts over the Life Cycle of Residential Buildings Using Different Exterior Wall SystemsJournal of Infrastructure Systems, 2009
- A review of the IPCC Assessment Report Four, Part 1: the IPCC process and greenhouse gas emission trends from buildings worldwideBuilding Services Engineering Research & Technology, 2008
- Economic Input-output Life-cycle Assessment of U.S. Residential BuildingsJournal of Infrastructure Systems, 2002