Comparing Flow-R, Rockyfor3D and RAMMS to Rockfalls from the Mel de la Niva Mountain: A Benchmarking Exercise
Open Access
- 30 June 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Geosciences
- Vol. 13 (7) , 200
Abstract
Rockfall simulations are often performed at various levels of detail depending on the required safety margins of rockfall-hazard-related assessments. As a pseudo benchmark, the simulation results from different models can be put side-by-side and compared with reconstructed rockfall trajectories, and mapped deposited block fragments from real events. This allows for assessing the objectivity, predictability, and sensitivity of the models. For this exercise, mapped data of past events from the Mel de la Niva site are used in this paper for a qualitative comparison with simulation results obtained from early calibration stages of the Flow-R 2.0.9, Rockyfor3D 5.2.15 and RAMMS::ROCKFALL 1.6.70 software. The large block fragments, reaching hundreds of megajoules during their fall, greatly exceed the rockfall energies of the empirical databases used for the development of most rockfall models. The comparison for this challenging site shows that the models could be improved and that combining the use of software programs with different behaviors could be a workaround in the interim. The findings also highlight the inconvenient importance of calibrating the simulations on a per-site basis from onsite observations. To complement this process, a back calculation tool is briefly described and provided. This work also emphasizes the need to better understand rockfall dynamics to help improve rebound models.Keywords
This publication has 51 references indexed in Scilit:
- Simulation of rockfall trajectories with consideration of rock shapeMultibody System Dynamics, 2013
- Design of rockfall protection embankments: A reviewEngineering Geology, 2013
- Technical Note: Preliminary estimation of rockfall runout zonesNatural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2011
- Half-scale experimental study of rockfall impacts on sandy slopesNatural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2009
- Quantitative assessment of the residual risk in a rockfall protected areaLandslides, 2005
- An attempt to refine rockfall hazard zoning based on the kinetic energy, frequency and fragmentation degreeNatural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2005
- Parametric evaluation of 3D dispersion of rockfall trajectoriesNatural Hazards and Earth System Sciences, 2004
- Hazard assessment in Switzerland - Codes of Practice for mass movementsBulletin of Engineering Geology and the Environment, 2002
- The assessment of rockfall hazard at the base of talus slopesCanadian Geotechnical Journal, 1993
- The prediction of hillslope flow paths for distributed hydrological modelling using digital terrain modelsHydrological Processes, 1991