Why does Income Relate to Depressive Symptoms? Testing the Income Rank Hypothesis Longitudinally
Open Access
- 28 October 2014
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Social Indicators Research
- Vol. 124 (2) , 637-655
Abstract
This paper reports a test of the relative income rank hypothesis of depression, according to which it is the rank position of an individual’s income amongst a comparison group, rather than the individual’s absolute income, that will be associated with depressive symptoms. A new methodology is developed to test between psychosocial and material explanations of why income relates to well-being. This method was used to test the income rank hypothesis as applied to depressive symptoms. We used data from a cohort of 10,317 individuals living in Wisconsin who completed surveys in 1992 and 2003. The utility assumed to arise from income was represented with a constant relative risk aversion function to overcome limitations of previous work in which inadequate specification of the relationship between absolute income and well-being may have inappropriately favoured relative income specifications. We compared models in which current and future depressive symptoms were predicted from: (a) income utility alone, (b) income rank alone, (c) the transformed difference between the individual’s income and the mean income of a comparison group and (d) income utility, income rank and distance from the mean jointly. Model comparison overcomes problems involving multi-collinearity amongst the predictors. A rank-only model was consistently supported. Similar results were obtained for the association between depressive symptoms and wealth and rank of wealth in a cohort of 32,900 British individuals who completed surveys in 2002 and 2008. We conclude that it is the rank of a person’s income or wealth within a social comparison group, rather than income or wealth themselves or their deviations from the mean within a reference group, that is more strongly associated with depressive symptoms.Keywords
This publication has 53 references indexed in Scilit:
- Country- and individual-level socioeconomic determinants of depression: multilevel cross-national comparisonThe British Journal of Psychiatry, 2013
- Economic Grand Rounds: Income Inequality and Depression Prevalence Across the United States: An Ecological StudyPsychiatric Services, 2011
- The happiness–income paradox revisitedProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2010
- Social comparisons and health: Can having richer friends and neighbors make you sick?Social Science & Medicine, 2009
- Do social comparisons explain the association between income inequality and health?: Relative deprivation and perceived health among male and female Japanese individualsSocial Science & Medicine, 2008
- Does Wage Rank Affect Employees’ Well‐being?Industrial Relations: A Journal of Economy and Society, 2008
- Health, income and relative deprivation: Evidence from the BHPSJournal of Health Economics, 2008
- The case for psychological treatment centresBMJ, 2006
- Income Inequality and Health: What Does the Literature Tell Us?Annual Review of Public Health, 2000
- The CES-D ScaleApplied Psychological Measurement, 1977