Narrowing the Definition of Endangered Species: Implications of the U.S. Government's Interpretation of the Phrase “A Significant Portion of its Range” Under the Endangered Species Act of 1973
- 24 March 2009
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Human Dimensions of Wildlife
- Vol. 14 (2) , 73-88
Abstract
In 2007, the Solicitor for the Department of Interior advocated for an interpretation of the phrase, “a significant portion of its range,” that would effectively narrow the definition of endangered species under the Endangered Species Act. We review the controversy concerning the government's interpretation of the “significant portion of its range” phrase, focusing on recent case law, the Solicitor's Memorandum, and relevant listing actions. We concentrate our discussion on two key conclusions reached by the Solicitor: (a) the term “range” in the phrase refers only to a species' current range, not its historical range and (b) the government is entitled to adapt its definition of the term “significant” on a case by case basis. We find that implementation of the Solicitor's interpretation could significantly reduce the number of species that qualify for protections and ultimately, result in a diminished capacity to provide for the conservation of threatened and endangered species.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Normativity ReduxConservation Biology, 2007
- A Biological Framework for Evaluating Whether a Species Is Threatened or Endangered in a Significant Portion of Its RangeConservation Biology, 2007
- The Normative Dimension and Legal Meaning of Endangered and Recovery in the U.S. Endangered Species ActConservation Biology, 2006
- Resolving Critical Habitat Designation Failures: Reconciling Law, Policy, and BiologyConservation Biology, 2006
- The Effectiveness of the Endangered Species Act: A Quantitative AnalysisBioScience, 2005
- It’s about Time: Conservation Biology and HistoryConservation Biology, 1999
- Arbitrary and Capricious Species ConservationConservation Biology, 1998
- Implementing the Endangered Species ActBioScience, 1996
- Property Rights Case Law and the Challenge to the Endangered Species ActConservation Biology, 1995
- Recovery Plans and the Endangered Species Act: Are Criticisms Supported by Data?Conservation Biology, 1995