Can the Reparability of Meniscal Tears Be Predicted With Magnetic Resonance Imaging?
- 20 December 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in The American Journal of Sports Medicine
- Vol. 39 (3) , 506-510
Abstract
Background: Historically, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) has been very useful in diagnosing meniscal tears but not as valuable in predicting whether a meniscal tear is reparable. Given that several recent studies suggested that MRI can be used to predict tear reparability, the topic has resurfaced as a controversy in the orthopaedic and radiology literatures. Hypothesis: Experienced musculoskeletal radiologists can use MRI to predict the reparability of meniscal tears with good to excellent accuracy using the same arthroscopic criteria used by surgeons intraoperatively. Study Design: Cohort study (diagnosis); Level of evidence, 3. Methods: Fifty-eight patients with meniscal tears treated with repair were matched by age and sex with 61 patients with tears treated with meniscectomy. Two senior musculoskeletal radiologists independently and blindly reviewed preoperative MRI of these 119 meniscal tears. Using established arthroscopic criteria, the radiologists were asked to grade each tear 0 to 4, with 1 point for each of the following: a tear larger than 10 mm, within 3 mm of the meniscosynovial junction, greater than 50% thickness, and with an intact inner meniscal fragment. Only a tear with a score of 4 would be predicted to be reparable. Results: The 2 radiologists’ ability to correctly estimate reparability was poor, with 58.0% and 62.7% correct predictions (κ = 0.155 and 0.250, respectively). Interrater reliability assessment showed that the raters agreed on a score of 4 (reparable) versus 2 = 14.9, P <.001). Conclusion: Magnetic resonance imaging is not an effective or efficient predictor of reparability of meniscal tears with the current arthroscopic criteria.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Comparison of the Accuracy Rates of 3-T and 1.5-T MRI of the Knee in the Diagnosis of Meniscal TearAmerican Journal of Roentgenology, 2009
- High-resolution Magnetic Resonance Imaging and Conventional Magnetic Resonance Imaging on a Standard Field-strength Magnetic Resonance System Compared to Arthroscopy in Patients with Suspected Meniscal TearsAcademic Radiology, 2008
- Magnetic resonance imaging as a tool to predict reparability of longitudinal full‐thickness meniscus lesionsKnee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy, 2008
- UTILIZATION OF ORTHOPAEDIC SERVICES IN A CAPITATED POPULATIONJournal of Bone and Joint Surgery, 2002
- A Clinical Study of Collagen Meniscus Implants to Restore the Injured MeniscusClinical Orthopaedics and Related Research, 1999
- Magnetic Resonance Imaging as a Tool to Predict Meniscal ReparabilityThe American Journal of Sports Medicine, 1999
- Meniscal RepairClinics in Sports Medicine, 1991
- Meniscal tears: The effect of meniscectomy and of repair on intraarticular contact areas and stress in the human kneeThe American Journal of Sports Medicine, 1986
- Arthroscopic meniscal repair evaluated with repeat arthroscopyArthroscopy, 1986
- The microvasculature of the meniscus and its response to injuryThe American Journal of Sports Medicine, 1983