Risk Prediction Models for Melanoma: A Systematic Review on the Heterogeneity in Model Development and Validation
Open Access
- 28 October 2020
- journal article
- review article
- Published by MDPI AG in International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health
- Vol. 17 (21) , 7919
Abstract
The rising incidence of cutaneous melanoma over the past few decades has prompted substantial efforts to develop risk prediction models identifying people at high risk of developing melanoma to facilitate targeted screening programs. We review these models, regarding study characteristics, differences in risk factor selection and assessment, evaluation, and validation methods. Our systematic literature search revealed 40 studies comprising 46 different risk prediction models eligible for the review. Altogether, 35 different risk factors were part of the models with nevi being the most common one (n = 35, 78%); little consistency in other risk factors was observed. Results of an internal validation were reported for less than half of the studies (n = 18, 45%), and only 6 performed external validation. In terms of model performance, 29 studies assessed the discriminative ability of their models; other performance measures, e.g., regarding calibration or clinical usefulness, were rarely reported. Due to the substantial heterogeneity in risk factor selection and assessment as well as methodologic aspects of model development, direct comparisons between models are hardly possible. Uniform methodologic standards for the development and validation of risk prediction models for melanoma and reporting standards for the accompanying publications are necessary and need to be obligatory for that reason.Keywords
This publication has 78 references indexed in Scilit:
- MC1Rgenotype as a predictor of early-onset melanoma, compared with self-reported and physician-measured traditional risk factors: an Australian case-control-family studyBMC Cancer, 2013
- Replication and Predictive Value of SNPs Associated with Melanoma and Pigmentation Traits in a Southern European Case-Control StudyPLOS ONE, 2013
- Systematic skin cancer screening in Northern GermanyJournal of the American Academy of Dermatology, 2012
- Developing risk prediction models for type 2 diabetes: a systematic review of methodology and reportingBMC Medicine, 2011
- Prediction models in cancer careCA: A Cancer Journal for Clinicians, 2011
- Development of an individual score for melanoma riskEuropean Journal Of Cancer Prevention, 2011
- Identifying individuals at high risk of melanoma: a simple toolEuropean Journal Of Cancer Prevention, 2010
- Reporting performance of prognostic models in cancer: a reviewBMC Medicine, 2010
- Assessing the Performance of Prediction ModelsEpidemiology, 2010
- Identifying people at high risk of cutaneous malignant melanoma: results from a case-control study in Western AustraliaBMJ, 1988