The ghosts of state terror: knowledge, politics and terrorism studies
- 10 December 2008
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Critical Studies on Terrorism
- Vol. 1 (3) , 377-392
Abstract
Employing a discourse analytic approach, this paper examines the silence on state terrorism within the broader terrorism studies literature. An analysis of this literature reveals that state terrorism is noticeable mainly for its absence as a subject of systematic academic study. Following the textual analysis, the main finding – the silence on state terrorism within terrorism studies – is subjected to both a first- and second-order critique. A first-order or immanent critique uses a discourse's internal contradictions, mistakes and misconceptions to criticise it on its own terms. In this case, the absence of state terrorism is criticised for its illogical actor-based definition of terrorism, its politically biased research focus, and its failure to acknowledge the empirical evidence of the extent and nature of state terrorism. A second-order critique entails reflecting on the broader political and ethical consequences of the representations enabled by the discourse. It is argued that the absence of state terrorism from academic discourse functions to promote particular kinds of state hegemonic projects, construct a legitimising public discourse for foreign and domestic policy, and deflect attention from the terroristic practices of states. The exposure and destabilisation of this dominant narrative also opens up critical space for the articulation of alternative and potentially emancipatory forms of knowledge and practice.Keywords
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- The end of terrorism studiesCritical Studies on Terrorism, 2008
- Veil and four walls: a state of terror in Pakistan1Critical Studies on Terrorism, 2008
- Still training to torture? US training of military forces from Latin AmericaThird World Quarterly, 2006
- ‘Iron Fists in Iron Gloves’: The Political Economy of US Terrorocracy Promotion in ColombiaThe British Journal of Politics and International Relations, 2006
- TerrortoryAlternatives: Global, Local, Political, 2006
- Terrorism as Deviance or Social ControlInternational Journal of Comparative Sociology, 2005
- State Torture in the Contemporary WorldInternational Journal of Comparative Sociology, 2005
- The Devil You Know: Continuing Problems with Research on TerrorismTerrorism and Political Violence, 2001
- Terrorism dissertations and the evolution of a specialty: An analysis of meta‐informationTerrorism and Political Violence, 1999
- Discourse, Ideology, Discourse, Ideology, Discourse, Ideology...The British Journal of Sociology, 1993