Transcatheter Aortic Valve Implantation in Centers Without Cardiac Surgery: A Preliminary Medico-Legal Discussion in Italy
Open Access
Abstract
Background/Objectives: The expansion of minimally invasive and transcatheter approaches has progressively blurred boundaries between medical and surgical disciplines. Valvular heart diseases, especially aortic ones, exemplify this translational shift, with transcatheter aortic valve implantation (TAVI) increasingly replacing conventional cardiac surgery. Current guidelines recommend the performance of these procedures in centers equipped with on-site cardiac surgery, ensuring management of time-dependent complications. In fact, even if the incidence of major complications is low, the absence of immediate surgical bailout may translate into a concrete loss of therapeutic opportunity. Methods: The authors discuss the forensic implications of performing TAVI in centers without on-site cardiac surgery. Results: Patient safety is an integral component of the right to health, emphasizing risks minimization. Structural or logistical inability to manage foreseeable complications, or safety mechanisms constraint in elective treatments may therefore constitute a harm of this right. In this context, several aspects must be considered in light of guideline evidence and available data, including the training and competencies of medical and surgical specialties in Italy; the lack of data on the timing of complication management and related mortality, with the consequent hypothesis of therapeutic delay; and the liability of Heart Team members in cases of deviation from the guidelines. Moreover, the issue of proximity of care and the Heart Valve Center model and the adequacy of patient information must be considered. Conclusion: Overall, while TAVI represents a major advance, it must be supported by organizational models proportionate to its complexity, integrating patient safety, healthcare accountability, and patient’s right to health.Keywords
This publication has 63 references indexed in Scilit:
- Contemporary Operator Procedural Volumes and Outcomes for TAVR and MTEER in the USJAMA Cardiology, 2026
- Cardiovascular and Non‐Cardiovascular Complications of Transcatheter Aortic Valve ImplantationCatheterization and Cardiovascular Interventions, 2025
- Emergent Cardiac Surgery After Transcatheter Structural Heart Procedures: Narrative ReviewCatheterization and Cardiovascular Interventions, 2025
- Major Intraprocedural Complications During Transcatheter Aortic Valve Implantation Requiring Emergent Cardiac Surgery: An Updated Systematic ReviewThe American Journal of Cardiology, 2025
- Death on waiting list for transcatheter aortic valve implantation: Current incidence, clinical characteristics and predictive factorsArchives of Cardiovascular Diseases, 2025
- Transcatheter aortic‐valve implantation with or without on‐site cardiac surgery: The TRACS trialAmerican Heart Journal, 2024
- Outcomes of emergent cardiac surgery after transcatheter aortic valve implantationNetherlands Heart Journal, 2023
- Improving access to transcatheter aortic valve implantation across Europe by restructuring cardiovascular services: An expert council consensus statementCatheterization and Cardiovascular Interventions, 2023
- Constraints on Medical Liability Through Malpractice Safe HarborsJAMA Health Forum, 2020
- Medicolegal Characteristics of Cardiac Catheterization Litigation in the United States, 1985 to 2009The American Journal of Cardiology, 2013