The 1-hour post-load glucose level is more effective than HbA1c for screening dysglycemia
- 21 January 2016
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Acta Diabetologica
- Vol. 53 (4) , 543-550
Abstract
Aim To assess the performance of HbA1c and the 1-h plasma glucose (PG ≥ 155 mg/dl; 8.6 mmol/l) in identifying dysglycemia based on the oral glucose tolerance test (OGTT) from a real-world clinical care setting. Methods This was a diagnostic test accuracy study. For this analysis, we tested the HbA1c diagnostic criteria advocated by the American Diabetes Association (ADA 5.7–6.4 %) and International Expert Committee (IEC 6.0–6.4 %) against conventional OGTT criteria. We also tested the utility of 1-h PG ≥ mg/dl; 8.6 mmol/l. Prediabetes was defined according to ADA-OGTT guidelines. Spearman correlation tests were used to determine the relationships between HbA1c, 1-h PG with fasting, 2-h PG and indices of insulin sensitivity and β-cell function. The levels of agreement between diagnostic methods were ascertained using Cohen’s kappa coefficient (Κ). Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve was used to analyze the performance of the HbA1c and 1-h PG test in identifying prediabetes considering OGTT as reference diagnostic criteria. The diagnostic properties of different HbA1c thresholds were contrasted by determining sensitivity, specificity and likelihood ratios (LR). Results Of the 212 high-risk individuals, 70 (33 %) were identified with prediabetes, and 1-h PG showed a stronger association with 2-h PG, insulin sensitivity index, and β-cell function than HbA1c (P < 0.05). Furthermore, the level of agreement between 1-h PG ≥ 155 mg/dl (8.6 mmol/l) and the OGTT (Κ[95 % CI]: 0.40[0.28–0.53]) diagnostic test was stronger than that of ADA-HbA1c criteria 0.1[0.03–0.16] and IEC criteria (0.17[0.04–0.30]). The ROC (AUC[95 % CI]) for HbA1c and 1-h PG were 0.65[0.57–0.73] and 0.79[0.72–0.85], respectively. Importantly, 1-h PG ≥ 155 mg/dl (8.6 mmol/l) showed good sensitivity (74.3 % [62.4–84.0]) and specificity 69.7 % [61.5–77.1]) with a LR of 2.45. The ability of 1-h PG to discriminate prediabetes was better than that of HbA1c (∆AUC: −0.14; Z value: 2.5683; P = 0.01022). Conclusion In a real-world clinical practice setting, the 1-h PG ≥ 155 mg/dl (8.6 mmol/l) is superior for detecting high-risk individuals compared with HbA1c. Furthermore, HbA1c is a less precise correlate of insulin sensitivity and β-cell function than the 1-h PG and correlates poorly with the 2-h PG during the OGTT.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases (NIH-K24-NR012226)
This publication has 40 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Early Diabetes Intervention Program – is early actually late?Diabetes/Metabolism Research and Reviews, 2014
- Trends in lifetime risk and years of life lost due to diabetes in the USA, 1985–2011: a modelling studyThe Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology, 2014
- Role of Reduced β-Cell Mass Versus Impaired β-Cell Function in the Pathogenesis of Type 2 DiabetesDiabetes Care, 2013
- Haemoglobin glycation may partly explain the discordance between HbA1c measurement and oral glucose tolerance test to diagnose dysglycaemia in overweight/obese subjectsDiabetes & Metabolism, 2013
- Insulin Sensitivity, β-Cell Function, and Incretin Effect in Individuals With Elevated 1-Hour Postload Plasma Glucose LevelsDiabetes Care, 2012
- Hemoglobin A1c and glucose criteria identify different subjects as having type 2 diabetes in middle-aged and older populations: The KORA S4/F4 StudyAnnals of Medicine, 2010
- Chronic disease modeling and simulation softwareJournal of Biomedical Informatics, 2010
- Screening for Diabetes and Pre-Diabetes With Proposed A1C-Based Diagnostic CriteriaDiabetes Care, 2010
- How are we diagnosing cardiometabolic risk in primary care settings?Primary Care Diabetes, 2009
- Impaired Fasting Glucose and Impaired Glucose ToleranceDiabetes Care, 2007